I think you are right there's some disagreement that's not really being hashed out here and I'm not sure where I stand on that. But there's one thing that I think you are wrong about here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dakota
She did in fact return to touch the base she missed. She just did not properly retouch 1B, but she still can if she can beat the defense to the base, correct?
To get the out, does the defense have to appeal she did not "legally" retouch 1B?
|
They can appeal the miss of first base (if you categorize it as that) by touching first OR by touching the runner. It just has to be clear what they are appealing. So she doesn't get to try to beat the throw to first.