Quote:
Originally Posted by CecilOne
This is not about myths. 
A batted ball which goes directly to the catcher's bare or gloved hand and is caught by the catcher is a foul tip, live ball strike. 
USA RULES, below true or false:
A batted ball which goes directly to any part of the catcher or catcher's equipment BEFORE touching the catcher's hand, even if caught, is a foul ball.
Ignore the catch for an out possibility. 
If the above is true, why is it inconsistent with other fielders: who can bobble, kick, etc. and still have a catch as long as it does not touch the ground.  |
The rule used to include: and caught by another fielder".
IMO, it is a ridiculous rule. If the defense can make the play, they should e rewarded for it