Hypothetical Setting Scenario

[FMadera]

Now from the perspective of the setter who performed just that with the exact same scenario. What if the setter knew that they were really performing a lift/carry/throw? I realize that an authoritively executed set may not called as illegal. Opinions?

Make a deal with the setter. I won't set if you stop trying to ref.

In other words, I really couldn't care less what a setter "knows" he/she is doing, I base my call on what I see.