The Official Forum - Interference @ Plate ?

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Softball (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/)

- - Interference @ Plate ? (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/53436-interference-plate.html)

Interference @ Plate ?

Can someone please state clearly as well as reference a rule as to when on a play at the plate between the catcher and a runner is considered 'interference' vs. 'obstruction' vs. 'incidental contact - (as they say in socer) play on'

(1) Runner coming around to score is heading towards home and of course is not looking back at the ball. The throw is up the line and the catcher runs up the line to catch the ball and runs into the runner. Result: Runner is knocked off his path......

Ruling: Obstruction ?

(2) Same play, ball gets to the catcher a split second prior to the runner and the runner runs into the catcher.....Result: catcher drops ball; runner scores

Ruling: Interference ?

(3) Same play, ball and runner get to the catcher @ approximately the same time and there is a collision (catcher is in the proper position on/in front of the plat)....Result: catcher drops ball; runner scores

Ruling: Incidental contact; play continues.

Please direct me to the ASA rule(s) that apply?

Thanks

Quote:

Originally Posted by bd41flpk (Post 605728)

(1) runner coming around to score is heading towards home and of course is not looking back at the ball. The throw is up the line and the catcher runs up the line to catch the ball and runs into the runner. Result: Runner is knocked off his path......

Ruling: Obstruction ?

ASA Rule 8-5-B

Quote:

Originally Posted by bd41flpk (Post 605728)

(2) same play, ball gets to the catcher a split second prior to the runner and the runner runs into the catcher.....result: Catcher drops ball; runner scores

ruling: Interference ?

8-7-Q

Quote:

Originally Posted by bd41flpk (Post 605728)

(3) same play, ball and runner get to the catcher @ approximately the same time and there is a collision (catcher is in the proper position on/in front of the plat)....result: Catcher drops ball; runner scores

ruling: Incidental contact; play continues.

RS13-G

Thanks much for the rules clarifications.....

Let me start from the bottom up:

(3) Rules Supplement 13.G - spells the 'incidental contact' out perfectly !

(2) Rule 8-7-Q - It is quite clear that (no matter the time involved) if the defensive player has the ball PRIOR to the (crash flavor) contact by the offensive player and their is contact...the onus is on the offensive player to avoid contact - hence, this is definitely Interference.

(1) Rule 8-5-B The rule definitely describes the essence of OBS; so it would seem that the catcher w/o the ball has the onus of avoiding the offensive player. However; when I read Rules Supplement 36.B - I interpret some 'grey area' - '.....Not in the act of fielding a ball.....' In my scenario, the catcher is in fact 'in the act of fielding the ball'. Yet I believe that this was in fact changed a while ago? I do believe that this is OBS; yet this statement definitely leads to some questions?

Any help with this interpretation is appreciated.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bd41flpk (Post 606349)

However; when I read Rules Supplement 36.B - I interpret some 'grey area' - '.....Not in the act of fielding a ball.....' In my scenario, the catcher is in fact 'in the act of fielding the ball'. Yet I believe that this was in fact changed a while ago? I do believe that this is OBS; yet this statement definitely leads to some questions?

Any help with this interpretation is appreciated.

Not in the act of fielding the ball refers to fielding a batted ball. In the act of fielding a thrown ball does not protect the defense from obstruction.