Appeal Play

Two out and R2 on 3rd. B1 hits the ball to the outfield. B1 winds up at 3rd. A valid appeal is made to the BU for the B1 missing 1st and he calls her out for the third out. Does the R2's score count or not? I know this is a time play

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by goldcoastump

Two out and R2 on 3rd. B1 hits the ball to the outfield. B1 winds up at 3rd. A valid appeal is made to the BU for the B1 missing 1st and he calls her out for the third out. Does the R2's score count or not? I know this is a time play

No, the run does not count, and no, this is not a time play. Since the base missed was 1B, the third out of the inning was on the BR at 1B, therefore, no runs score.

Do you have a FED rule or case book page to back that up? I could not find anything.

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by goldcoastump

Do you have a FED rule or case book page to back that up? I could not find anything.

Fed Rule 9-1-1

EXCEPTION: A run is not scored if the runner advances to home plate during action in which the third out is made as follows:
a. by the batter-runner before touching first base;

Fed Case Book

9.1.1 SITUATION C: With two outs and R1 on first, B4 hits an inside-the-park
home run. In circling the bases, B4 misses second. RULING: If appealed properly,
the umpire will call B4 out for missing second base. The run scored by R1 will
count. Had the infraction been missing first base, the run by R1 would have been
canceled. (8-3-1, 8; 9-1-1 Exception a; 2-1)

Thanks

[Chess Ref]

Originally Posted by Dakota

Fed Rule 9-1-1

Fed Case Book

Just curious, do you have all this memorized or do you look it up like the rest of us feebs....

[Dakota]

Of course I have it memorized... don't you??? After all, to keep up with the ASA banned bats list, my eidetic memory is darned handy!

[charliej47]

You can download the NFHS rule set for baseball and softball along with the case plays. This will allow you to do quick searches like I do when trying to find the answer.