Ms

[SC Ump]

Originally Posted by UmpireErnie

Yep, you got it wrong.

When BR passes R1, R1 is immediately out.

Agree with everything except what I think is a typo on your part: BR is out as supported by everything else you posted.

Bobrix - I think in your description, you have BR "turn into" R2 when they touched first base. In describing plays like this, it is traditional that the BR stays the BR for the whole play. Likewise, if a play had started with the bases loaded, R2 would not turn into R1 if an out was made.