Fair or Foul

[debeau]

You are right in your thinking .
The ump gave his/her decision based on judgement of where they thought the ball was and may have not clarified that point .
It seems it was a fairly ( no pun ) close call and I would say the plate ump should have been in a better position than yourself .
The good point is you know what fair/foul is . Your fist step to Bluedom