WCWS: Catch or no catch?
UW vs OU; https://youtu.be/mQdLcJc0gj4?t=97
I've watched this 20 times to come to my conclusion. Thoughts? There is a video on ESPN with a few more replay angles, but I don't know how to link to their videos. EDIT: 1:13 here https://www.ncaa.com/video/softball/...e-2-highlights |
That ball never stopped moving and was definitely not lost on transfer.
|
The more I watch it, the more I lean toward a "no catch"
What I am seeing: Ball loosely in the glove and snow coning. The fielder's hand coming up and holding the glove. As the ball starts to come out of the glove, the bare hand getting underneath the ball. At this point, the angle becomes very difficult. To me it seems the fielder is still trying to get a grip on the ball and she is holding it against her body. In less than a half a second, we see the ball come shooting out from the other side or her body. IMO, I never see incontrovertible evidence of possession or control of the ball. Yes, it was difficult to determine after watching it by frame a half-dozen + times and the umpire on the field has to go with the gut feeling at that time. I have no problem with the call as made, but can completely understand if it went the other way. |
Quote:
From the case book: Quote:
And the stupid announcer comment of the night, the between games crew said: "in softball, the ball doesn't need to survive the ground." The unfortunate part about this play is PU was the primary for this play. With a runner on second, counter-rotated starting position, this is PU's area of responsibility. Although there is a alternate mechanic (circa 2016) that allows U1 to help on catch/no catch (all the way to the line), this is still a difficult play. And now the calls for 4 umpires (as happened in the FSU regional game, FSU vs. Auburn). Well, and replay. :rolleyes: |
Quote:
Quote:
|
This play is so close that I do not believe that you can fault the umpire with either call she/he makes in this situation. I think that it comes down to communication skills (explaining why a certain call was made) and game management skills.
|
Quote:
|
Sitting here with my "OU" shirt on, it would be easy to say there is no way that met the definition of a catch. But, it was awful close, and a really difficult call in real time. I'm happy to let the call stand, as I've been there and had to make the same judgement, myself.
|
There was another very similar catch/no catch in today's game in right field. The Washington right fielder seems adept at selling no catches.
|
Quote:
Blown call at 1B. Blown call on the "hit near the foot and popped up" play. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:55pm. |