BR Interference

[AtlUmpSteve]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

Now that you mentioned it, I assume the running lane guide still applies if the BU is in the C slot?

I have a very strong "it depends" on that; and it leads to one area where mechanics vary based on who taught you, with a strong 50/50 issue.

For the most part, I'm a believer that standard mechanics with the fewest exceptions is the best path for all. And for the "did she step back" case, the standard remains best, as the perpendicular you mention is a great angle.

BUT, in the case of a tag to either side that BU simply cannot possibly judge the straight line, I would vary and make the call emphatically as the PU, hopefully well before the BU guesses. Because, that leads to the 50/50 issue.

Half the softball umpire world says BU should make the call based on what he sees, because the mechanics say it is the BU call, and be prepared to go for help if asked (or even insinuated) by either team. The other half of the world says BU should ask immediately, without ever making a call; and that potentially throws the PU under the bus if, for whatever reason, PU doesn't have a good look at the play that really isn't his call.

So, if I, as PU, have a clear and definitive angle, I'm making that call; even when my partner might think I'm poaching .