The Official Forum  

Go Back   The Official Forum > Search Forums
Reload this Page Search Results
Register FAQ Members List Social Groups Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Page 1 of 2 1 2
Showing results 1 to 25 of 27
Search took 0.00 seconds. Search: Posts Made By: KWH
Forum: Football Sat Aug 15, 2009, 02:05am
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Question What the he11?

Huh? :confused:
Forum: Football Fri Aug 14, 2009, 04:41pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
I just wanted to be comment #200!

I just wanted to be comment #200!
Forum: Football Fri Aug 14, 2009, 03:26pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
My point is our charter is to determine if the...

My point is our charter is to determine if the play is legal.
And, since the player involved was "not out of bounds by rule",
the play has to be legal.

Determining the status of the player is...
Forum: Football Fri Aug 14, 2009, 03:12pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Jim D- You continue to answer the question...

Jim D-

You continue to answer the question with a question. Unfortunatly however,
you failed to list the correct answer in your multiple choice question as his status is not out of bounds.
...
Forum: Football Fri Aug 14, 2009, 12:39pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Post Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

So Alf (aka, AJMC), and his special alter-ego cousin Adolf (aka, ASDF) are working a huge saturday morning Pop Warner 3rd/4th grade tilt, score is tied at 0-0 with :30 remaining in the contest when...
Forum: Football Thu Aug 13, 2009, 04:22pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
From the Rules Book

Alf-

In response to your request of: ..."Surely, someone as intelligent as you could easily persuade a dolt like me that there is some (any) rational basis for your interpretation"...

That...
Forum: Football Thu Aug 06, 2009, 12:57pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Alf- I did just as you ask; The author based...

Alf-
I did just as you ask;
The author based his interpretation solely on the wording in the NFHS Rules Book!
Forum: Football Fri Jul 31, 2009, 06:32pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Thumbs down Welpe, you are mistaken.

Welpe-
1) George did not write this case play but I know who did!
2) I do not know where or from whom you are getting your information, but the information you are providing is inaccurate! Why?...
Forum: Football Fri Jul 31, 2009, 03:15pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Thumbs up Legal Play

This just in!

August 2009 REFEREE Magazine (Page 20) prints this exact play.

Ruling - LEGAL PLAY.

Before some of you start slamming REFEREE Magazine my understanding is all the case plays...
Forum: Football Tue Jul 28, 2009, 02:07pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
I vote for Rogers Redding

My vote goes with the Redding interpretation also.

Anybody know how to set up one of thoses voting polls on this site?
Forum: Football Tue Jul 28, 2009, 01:33pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Thumbs down I also disagree with Alf

MikeL brings up an excellant point. Lets take another look at Alf's philosophy of: ...I'm going with what makes the most sense to me and my understanding of this game. That's a decision everyone has...
Forum: Football Mon Jul 27, 2009, 08:33pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Alf- In NFHS Football there is no such thing as...

Alf-
In NFHS Football there is no such thing as an inbounds player. Unless of course you are referring to a player who is standing inside the hashmarks! :confused:
Perhaps you should read Rule...
Forum: Football Mon Jul 27, 2009, 06:35pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Post Alf- You post above has two incorrect...

Alf-
You post above has two incorrect statements:

1) You wrote: "The rule is question uses the word "touching"..."
The actual wording in the rule in question is: ...is touching...

2) You...
Forum: Football Mon Jul 27, 2009, 01:48pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Post I'm with Berkut! And I would add there is Rules...

I'm with Berkut!
And I would add there is Rules Book support for Berkut's ruling.

As for Alf, I can find no Rules Book support for:
"a player who has clearly established himself OOB, continues...
Forum: Football Mon Jul 27, 2009, 10:58am
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Post Alf- Your sample play is legal.

Legal play!
When the airbourne PLAYER batted the football, such PLAYER, by NFHS definition, is not out of bounds as per: NFHS 2-29-1.
Therefore, by rule, this play is legal as the ball did not...
Forum: Football Sun Jul 26, 2009, 04:10pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Huh?

Huh?
Alf-
Are you so anal retentive that you can't see, on this entire thread, no one supports your opinion? Is it possible you could be wrong? Or, are you so far superior to the rest of us peons...
Forum: Football Sat Jul 25, 2009, 02:15pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Alf- One simple question: 1) Can you...

Alf-

One simple question:

1) Can you please explain why, the NFHS continues to defy any sense of logic, common sense and the basic tone of the game by annually refusing to change the wording of...
Forum: Football Thu Jul 23, 2009, 05:50pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Post Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

Alf-
The interpretation I have presented is that of the NFHS!
In theory, that should be sufficient for every one of your requirements.

As for your opinion that, "...we are each free to follow...
Forum: Football Thu Jul 23, 2009, 01:07pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Alf- We all clearly understand your point, and...

Alf-
We all clearly understand your point, and I am beyond certain however you will repeat it 7 more times! However, the play in the OP and the play in the Redding Study Guide were discussed at the...
Forum: Football Thu Jul 23, 2009, 12:50pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Thumbs down Just because you are NOT OOB does not mean you are inbounds!

While many feel the need to belabor the point, the rule book remains silent on "inbounds" and as such, their is no definition of an inbounds player. However, there is a clear definition of when a...
Forum: Football Wed Apr 22, 2009, 04:42pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Cool Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

I stand corrected!
For those of you who sent me Private messages telling me I am wasting my time even responding to this guy, you were right, I was wrong. And, as one of you so eliquently coined a...
Forum: Football Wed Apr 22, 2009, 12:23pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Cool Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

AJMC-
I have two "resonable polite" questions for you:
1) I am wondering if you as of yet have "empowered yourself" with the opportunity to discuss this play your State Rules Interpreter and thus...
Forum: Football Tue Apr 21, 2009, 12:08pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

AJMC & Jim D -

I suggest you present this particular play to your respective State Rules Interpreters. In fairness, I suggest you present them with both the AJMC/JIMD interpretation along with the...
Forum: Football Mon Apr 20, 2009, 02:55pm
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

Jim D-

Hey Jim, please don't misunderstand, I don't like this any more than you do!

That being said:

The rule book most certainly and unequivocally tells us he is not out-of-bounds!
Rule...
Forum: Football Mon Apr 20, 2009, 11:01am
Replies: 207
Views: 25,396
Posted By KWH
Never let the rule book get in the way of a good football game!

AJMC-
Consider this.
If you are a rule book guy, you almost certainly would have to agree that by definition (Rule 2-29) the player was NOT Out of Bounds. With all due respect, you continue to...
Showing results 1 to 25 of 27
Page 1 of 2 1 2

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:50am.

The Official Forum - Archive - Top


Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1