The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   PSK frequency and the bean bag (https://forum.officiating.com/football/9951-psk-frequency-bean-bag.html)

Rich Sat Sep 06, 2003 12:11am

I remember looking at the slide show where the NFHS claims that a PSK situation happens only once every 8-10 games.

I've worked 3 games this season and have had 2 PSK situations -- an invalid fair catch signal and a block in the back by the short punt returner on a defender just before the other deep guy caught the ball.

While having 2 of these in 3 games might be much, I just can't imagine having only one every 8-10 games.

Working 4-man the other night as the LJ, I was bean bagging the PSK spot and we had some long returns. Anyone figure out how to get the bean bag back to the LJ (or BJ in 5-man)?

Rich


BktBallRef Sat Sep 06, 2003 02:19am

Quote:

Originally posted by Rich Fronheiser
I remember looking at the slide show where the NFHS claims that a PSK situation happens only once every 8-10 games.

I've worked 3 games this season and have had 2 PSK situations -- an invalid fair catch signal and a block in the back by the short punt returner on a defender just before the other deep guy caught the ball.

While having 2 of these in 3 games might be much, I just can't imagine having only one every 8-10 games.

Rich, the referees in our association are supposed to be reporting them in their game reports each week. I haven't heard how many we've had through the first four weeks but I'll try to find out. Our crew hasn't had one this year, through 4 V and 3 JV games.

Quote:

Working 4-man the other night as the LJ, I was bean bagging the PSK spot and we had some long returns. Anyone figure out how to get the bean bag back to the LJ (or BJ in 5-man)?
Run Forrest, run! ;)

No other way that I know of.

Theisey Sat Sep 06, 2003 06:58am

It's a statistics thing Rich. They can make the numbers look any way they want them to look.

Game one for me last night. PSK in the first quarter.

bluduc Sat Sep 06, 2003 08:24am

3 varsity games and 9 sub-varsity games this season. 3 PSK in one varsity game, 5 in the sub-varsity games. We use NCAA rules. I think the one in eight or ten games is a bit low.
"Clean hands" rule may be one in eight or ten.

jack015 Sat Sep 06, 2003 08:50am

4 varsity games - zero PSK fouls. Closest thing I have seen was an invalid fair catch signal during a free kick, where PSK does not apply.

I worked with a R two Friday nights ago who said he had 1 PSK foul the week before.

Tom Hinrichs Sat Sep 06, 2003 10:21am

PSK
 
We had a PSK enforcement in our opener Friday night.

I guess that we are done with that particular situation for the seaons.

TXMike Sat Sep 06, 2003 10:36am

Using NCAA rules I see about 1 PSK situation every 3 - 4 games.

As for the bean bag, I used to be a real fan of "Top Cat", a cartoon back in the 60's. Remember how he had a quarter he used to tip the doorman but it had a thread on it so he could pull it back? I have a similar contraption on my bean bag so I can reel it in after the play.

J/K Just means I have to hustle a bit more but that is what we BJ's are known for right? Being hustlers.

Warrenkicker Sat Sep 06, 2003 12:42pm

Some are going to see PSK a couple times in one game and others may not see it this year. It has been 23 varsity games since I saw it last. Will probably see it next week now.

Ed Hickland Sat Sep 06, 2003 01:14pm

How many PSK fouls were with the ball in the air versus the ball bouncing around before possession?

The last one I saw, two seasons ago, the ball was bouncing before possession.

Warrenkicker Sat Sep 06, 2003 01:31pm

The last one I had was with the ball bouncing around and R never touched it. R clipped (today is was a block in the back) and gave K a first down.

Rich Sat Sep 06, 2003 06:16pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Ed Hickland
How many PSK fouls were with the ball in the air versus the ball bouncing around before possession?

The last one I saw, two seasons ago, the ball was bouncing before possession.

Both of mine (start of thread) were with the ball in the air.

It may have caused a lot of confusion early on, but there are a lot of instances where PSK makes a world of sense -- where an R foul after the kick would bail the K team out when the penalty put the ball past the line to gain.

Rich

JRutledge Sat Sep 06, 2003 07:30pm

I have had 3 weekends of football. One in Indiana, 2 in Illinois. This week was the first time we had a PSK on my regular crew during a Sophmore/JV game on Friday.

You throw the bean bag, you get your bean bag unless someone else sees it. Not much else you can do in those situations.

Peace

Forksref Sat Sep 06, 2003 07:37pm

I've had one in 6 games (invalid fair catch signal)

Carry two bean bags if you are LJ or BJ. Also, talking to statisticians, trainers, etc might help in retrieving it.

Ed Hickland Mon Sep 08, 2003 07:09pm

From our meeting last week, the New York state interpreter recommends having two bean bags and labeling the one used to mark the end of the scrimmage kick with a "K". That way if you use the secodn bag on the same play in the same area there will be no confusion.

pierre bertolino Thu Sep 11, 2003 01:36am

Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:

Originally posted by Rich Fronheiser
I remember looking at the slide show where the NFHS claims that a PSK situation happens only once every 8-10 games.

I've worked 3 games this season and have had 2 PSK situations -- an invalid fair catch signal and a block in the back by the short punt returner on a defender just before the other deep guy caught the ball.

While having 2 of these in 3 games might be much, I just can't imagine having only one every 8-10 games.

Rich, the referees in our association are supposed to be reporting them in their game reports each week. I haven't heard how many we've had through the first four weeks but I'll try to find out. Our crew hasn't had one this year, through 4 V and 3 JV games.

Quote:

Working 4-man the other night as the LJ, I was bean bagging the PSK spot and we had some long returns. Anyone figure out how to get the bean bag back to the LJ (or BJ in 5-man)?
Run Forrest, run! ;)

No other way that I know of.



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:12am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1