The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   Can offens grab facemask (https://forum.officiating.com/football/98374-can-offens-grab-facemask.html)

umpjim Mon Sep 08, 2014 09:27pm

Can offens grab facemask
 
BB guy. Watching ESPN Monday nite and they show Steve Smith of Ravens stiff arm defender and then pulling him to to the ground via the face mask. Can offense use the face mask?

APG Mon Sep 08, 2014 10:48pm

Both the offense and defense have the same rules in regard to facemask in the NFL. It's not a penalty simply to grab the facemask. It only becomes a penalty when they fail to release immediately and controls the opponent or grabs and pulls, twists, push, or pull the facemask.

Saying that, I haven't seen the play in question so can't comment.

umpjim Mon Sep 08, 2014 11:20pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by APG (Post 939957)
Both the offense and defense have the same rules in regard to facemask in the NFL. It's not a penalty simply to grab the facemask. It only becomes a penalty when they fail to release immediately and controls the opponent or grabs and pulls, twists, push, or pull the facemask.

Saying that, I haven't seen the play in question so can't comment.

I'll post some screen grabs tomorrow. IMHO, with an official looking right at it nothing was called. What got me was the ESPN twits.

Reffing Rev. Tue Sep 09, 2014 08:41am

I can count on one fist the number of times I've seen a ball carrier flagged for grabbing an opponent's facemask.

ajmc Tue Sep 09, 2014 12:06pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reffing Rev. (Post 939969)
I can count on one fist the number of times I've seen a ball carrier flagged for grabbing an opponent's facemask.

Can't speak for NFL rules, but otherwise NFHS 9-4-3-h prohibits "grasping an opponents facemask", and applies to EVERY player.

umpjim Tue Sep 09, 2014 12:28pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ajmc (Post 939987)
Can't speak for NFL rules, but otherwise NFHS 9-4-3-h prohibits "grasping an opponents facemask", and applies to EVERY player.

Can't get a pic uploaded due to 100kb limit so you will have to go here to see pics: Laredo Optimist LL Baseball: Albums

Click on the "football" album

ajmc Tue Sep 09, 2014 03:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by umpjim (Post 939991)
Can't get a pic uploaded due to 100kb limit so you will have to go here to see pics: Laredo Optimist LL Baseball: Albums Click on the "football" album

Can't see any "grasping" in any of these photos.

umpjim Tue Sep 09, 2014 10:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ajmc (Post 939998)
Can't see any "grasping" in any of these photos.

You would have to see the video to understand that the impetus for the defenders trajectory derived from the runners arm, wherever it was attached to, benefit of the doubt, horse collar, otherwise facemask?

MD Longhorn Wed Sep 10, 2014 07:50am

Quote:

Originally Posted by umpjim (Post 940017)
You would have to see the video to understand that the impetus for the defenders trajectory derived from the runners arm, wherever it was attached to, benefit of the doubt, horse collar, otherwise facemask?

I have seen the video. There's no grasping here, not once. "impetus for the defenders trajectory derived from the runners arm"????? That has nothing to do with anything at all. (And merely saying the term "horse collar" in the context of this play, where contact was entirely from the front, is particularly worrisome).

ajmc Wed Sep 10, 2014 08:03am

Quote:

Originally Posted by umpjim (Post 940017)
You would have to see the video to understand that the impetus for the defenders trajectory derived from the runners arm, wherever it was attached to, benefit of the doubt, horse collar, otherwise facemask?

Don't know which rule code your suggesting, but you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear under ANY of them.

JasonLJ Wed Sep 10, 2014 08:06am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reffing Rev. (Post 939969)
I can count on one fist the number of times I've seen a ball carrier flagged for grabbing an opponent's facemask.

I've called it twice. Can't grasp the facemask, period.

Welpe Wed Sep 10, 2014 08:14am

Quote:

Originally Posted by umpjim (Post 940017)
wherever it was attached to, benefit of the doubt, horse collar, otherwise facemask?

Here's where I think the disconnect lies. We are not supposed to guess why a player's head jerks around or how he suddenly and violently is yanked back to the ground. In these plays, if we don't know, we don't throw (or shouldn't anyways).

Many times guessing on facemasks and horsecollars result in an incorrect foul being called. This is a concept a fair amount of coaches don't seem to grasp and can't believe that we missed an "obvious" facemask.

umpjim Wed Sep 10, 2014 10:36am

Quote:

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn (Post 940022)
I have seen the video. There's no grasping here, not once. "impetus for the defenders trajectory derived from the runners arm"????? That has nothing to do with anything at all. (And merely saying the term "horse collar" in the context of this play, where contact was entirely from the front, is particularly worrisome).

I'm a BB guy so I ignorantly used that term to refer to grabbing the front of the shoulder pads. So, without solid evidence of why the defender is going down no official will call it a facemask. Makes sense. Thanks.

MD Longhorn Wed Sep 10, 2014 11:40am

Quote:

Originally Posted by umpjim (Post 940033)
I'm a BB guy so I ignorantly used that term to refer to grabbing the front of the shoulder pads. So, without solid evidence of why the defender is going down no official will call it a facemask. Makes sense. Thanks.

Players grab each other all the time. Defenders go down all the time. It's football.

Adam Wed Sep 10, 2014 05:06pm

Ball carriers will often stiff-arm a defender on his face without grasping it.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:29am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1