The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   Try after fair catch (https://forum.officiating.com/football/9827-try-after-fair-catch.html)

lawref Mon Aug 25, 2003 07:27pm

Has anyone ever had Team A try after a fair catch? Where is the rule in NFHS? I see it referenced, but not discussed directly. When would a team do it?

mpasenelli Mon Aug 25, 2003 07:48pm

Once in 25 years: Had a team elect to free kick after a fair catch shortly before half time. Had a very short punt from K's end zone, fair catch at K's 35, and the receiver told me he wanted to free kick. They didn't score, though.

Rule reference is 8-4-1a,
6-5-4,and 2-23-3. Case book 8.4.1B also gives a couple of examples.

Theisey Mon Aug 25, 2003 07:49pm

What a receiving team attempts to do is to "Free Kick" after a fair catch was made or an awarded fair catch.

See NF 6-5-4 for the gory details.

Never seen this in 18 years of NF football. I've heard of it but only through forums such as this.

Why they would do this? I can only guess that they are down by 3 points or less with maybe a couple ticks on the clock and have a very good free kicker as compare to a potent offense.

I say, free kicker, because that's how they line up. Just like for a free kick to start the game. There is no one in front of the kicker for 10 yards.

Someone else can fill in other details if you really want them.

SWFLguy Mon Aug 25, 2003 08:49pm

I never saw it in my 34 years----
heard about someone who had it !
probably most coaches would not even
understand it if it bit them in the
clipboard !

lawref Mon Aug 25, 2003 08:59pm

Great. Now we'll probably all have one during our first game this season!

Rich Tue Aug 26, 2003 06:49am

Wouldn't be a big deal. You'd line up just the same as you would for a kickoff, except you'd run the two deep officials (R and BJ) under the goalposts (5-man).

This can be done on a fair catch or on an awarded fair catch.

I've seen it once. The kick was wide. Best time would be near the end of a half.

This is just one of those things you have to know in case it ever happens. Kinda like being prepared for more than one legal forward pass in a high school game.

Rich

[Edited by Rich Fronheiser on Aug 26th, 2003 at 06:53 AM]

jay_a_29 Fri Aug 29, 2003 09:14am

Heard about this once...but one question
 
Can the kicking team use a tee for the free kick?

Rich Fri Aug 29, 2003 09:34am

Yes. It's a free kick. They can use a tee if they place kick, just like any other place kick under NFHS rules.

Now, this reminded me of a story I heard last week.

A shortage of football officials and the lack of any centralized assigning group means that where I live there is nothing to stop a rookie official from starting his own crew of rookie officials and then marketing that crew for Friday night games. For the most part that doesn't happen.

However, one such crew worked a varsity game a few seasons ago (I heard this third-hand, so I can't verify this, but I could picture it happening) and after a safety told the team about to free kick that they (1) couldn't use a tee and (2) couldn't punt. The referee told the coach that after a safety the kicking team had to lay the ball on the ground and kick it that way. I don't know if a holder was involved.

Like I said, it's a good story, even if it isn't true.

Rich

[Edited by Rich Fronheiser on Aug 29th, 2003 at 09:50 AM]

AndrewMcCarthy Fri Aug 29, 2003 09:34am

Re: Heard about this once...but one question
 
Quote:

Originally posted by jay_a_29
Can the kicking team use a tee for the free kick?
Yes, they may. They can use a place kick per NF 2-23-7 or a drop kick per NF 2-23-6.

Rich Fri Aug 29, 2003 09:51am

I've always wanted to see a team use a drop kick to kick off, but I never have.

Come to think of it, I have never seen a drop kick since I started working football.

Rich

jfurdell Fri Aug 29, 2003 11:11am

It's too hard to get a good bounce for a drop kick with our pointy-ended American footballs. That rule was more applicable when the ball looked and bounced more like a rugby ball, way back in the day.

Rich Fri Aug 29, 2003 11:31am

I was at the football HOF in Canton a few weeks ago. There they have a football from the 1890's. It was round on the ends, like a rugby ball.

I had a friend back in my hometown who could regularly drop-kick a 30 yard FG. What a freak.

Rich

rdfox Sat Aug 30, 2003 04:42pm

Our association came up this scenario...

R makes a fair catch on its own 10 yd line with three seconds to go in the first half. It then throws a "Hail Mary" pass which is caught by A80 at the fifty who is immediately tackled. Time has run out.

However, there was roughing the passer back in A's end zone.

Therefore, the penalty will be assessed to B's 35 and A is given an untimed down as a replay...They then have the right to choose a free kick for three points...from a tee...no snap...and no rush from B.

The one question we had as a group was, in explaining the penalty options to A, do we tell them of their right to a free kick? After discussion, we decided "No".

cowbyfan1 Sun Aug 31, 2003 05:56am

I actually saw it one time in a Pro game (drop kick that is). I want to say it was Randall Cunningham who did it but don't hold me to that as it was better than 10 years ago.

Theisey Sun Aug 31, 2003 07:15am

Quote:

Originally posted by rdfox
Our association came up this scenario...

R makes a fair catch on its own 10 yd line with three seconds to go in the first half. It then throws a "Hail Mary" pass which is caught by A80 at the fifty who is immediately tackled. Time has run out.

However, there was roughing the passer back in A's end zone.

Therefore, the penalty will be assessed to B's 35 and A is given an untimed down as a replay...They then have the right to choose a free kick for three points...from a tee...no snap...and no rush from B.

The one question we had as a group was, in explaining the penalty options to A, do we tell them of their right to a free kick? After discussion, we decided "No".

### this is actually an interesting question. While I don't have the exact words in front of me, I believe it says that Team-R has a choice of putting the ball in play by snap or free kick after a fair catch or awarded fair catch.

Do we ever ask them that the first time? Not being a WH, I don't know what he tells them, but it sounds like he should tell them at that point. Agree?

We all know we ask a team where they want the ball spotted for a TRY down because again, the rules say they have a choice of placement.

So with that, I'll go out on a limb and say yes, officials should probably tell the captain (not the coach) of the choice to snap or free kick still exists.

LDUB Mon Sep 01, 2003 03:28pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Rich Fronheiser
This is just one of those things you have to know in case it ever happens. Kinda like being prepared for more than one legal forward pass in a high school game.

[Edited by Rich Fronheiser on Aug 26th, 2003 at 06:53 AM]

Now I don't officiate football but i play football. Currentely I only officiate Baseball and Softball but I am in the process of adding basketball. But I plan on officiating football in a few years. So how is it possible to have 2 foreward passes on the same play legally? Also what does PSK mean? I read it all the time and I can't figure it out.

BktBallRef Mon Sep 01, 2003 03:30pm

Because the rules allow it. As long as each pass thrown from in or behind the neutral zone, the pass is legal.

JRutledge Mon Sep 01, 2003 05:16pm

Quote:

Originally posted by LDUB

So how is it possible to have 2 foreward passes on the same play legally?

NF is the only level that allows multiple forward passes, as long as the ball is from behind the Line of Scrimmage.

Quote:

Originally posted by LDUB

Also what does PSK mean? I read it all the time and I can't figure it out.

It means Post Scrimmage Kick. Basically it is a way to enforce penalties on a punt and field goal attempts that the Receiving team. NCAA and NFL all have a PSK enforcement and now the NF just put this rule in this year. It has caused a lot of confusion, so this is why you are seeing so much talk about PSK this year.

Peace

jrfath Wed Sep 03, 2003 01:52pm

In the 2003 Case book, page 46, 6.5.4 Situation B addresses this scenario...
__________________________________________________ ___
[


QUOTE]Originally posted by rdfox
Our association came up this scenario...

R makes a fair catch on its own 10 yd line with three seconds to go in the first half. It then throws a "Hail Mary" pass which is caught by A80 at the fifty who is immediately tackled. Time has run out.

However, there was roughing the passer back in A's end zone.

Therefore, the penalty will be assessed to B's 35 and A is given an untimed down as a replay...They then have the right to choose a free kick for three points...from a tee...no snap...and no rush from B.

The one question we had as a group was, in explaining the penalty options to A, do we tell them of their right to a free kick? After discussion, we decided "No".
[/QUOTE]

JimNayzium Thu Sep 04, 2003 07:41pm

Coach's take on this again...

1. First of all I love the hail mary scenario...nice work...

2. As a coach I have def tried a free kick after fair catch...and have scored a touchdown in the state championship game on two forward passes....nice reference again...in fact when i found this rule i designed a play just to say i had done it...we called it "the dumb play" in the huddle...not so dumb after it scored...haha...

3. TRUE story here which is funny...Michael Groh the quarterback at UVA a couple of years back is one of my close friends...he kicked a 37 yard field goal to win his state chmpionship his senior year...it made like the 44th game in a row they won...the funny thing is he fair caught the punt with eight seconds left on the twenty and they did not know they coudl free kick...his thirty seven yarder squeeked in the right upright....pretty good a coach could win forty four in a row and not know the rule on this one...

4. Interesting tid bit...I have the state record fg in sc with a 61 yarder but the record books don't differ from a free kick and a fg...which they should...

the high school sixty eight yarder was a free kick....there has been a high school sixty seven yard fg, but i am pretty sure borgogone's sixty eight yearder was a free kick...dont yall think there should be a free kick record and a field goal record???

Jaguar Mon Sep 15, 2003 10:41pm

Speak of the devil...
 
Central wins on rare kick

http://www.kansas.com/mld/kansas/sports/6760515.htm

Bob M. Wed Sep 17, 2003 03:48pm

Quote:

Originally posted by JimNayzium
Coach's take on this again...

3. TRUE story here which is funny...Michael Groh the quarterback at UVA a couple of years back is one of my close friends...he kicked a 37 yard field goal to win his state chmpionship his senior year...it made like the 44th game in a row they won...the funny thing is he fair caught the punt with eight seconds left on the twenty and they did not know they coudl free kick...his thirty seven yarder squeeked in the right upright....pretty good a coach could win forty four in a row and not know the rule on this one...


REPLY: I distinctly remember this. Randolph HS vs. Montclair HS. Groh was the QB and kicker for Randolph. It was 1990, I think. I had just finished officiating another group's championship game and was driving home when I heard about it on the radio. Rather than drive directly home, I went to my parents' house to watch it on cable TV. I'm not sure that their coach (Bauer) didn't know the rule. There may have been another explanation. Here's what I saw. The punt was very high but very, very short. The receiver signalled and came running up hard to make the catch. He actually dove and made the catch just before he hit the ground. BUT...I'm not sure that the kick ever crossed the NZ. In that case, the ball was dead because of the signal, but it would <u>not</u> be a fair catch and they would have no choice but to kick the FG from a conventional scrimmage kick formation. The officials on that game were from outside our chapter, so I never got their perspective.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:49pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1