The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   Intentional Grounding (https://forum.officiating.com/football/92314-intentional-grounding.html)

jimpiano Sun Sep 02, 2012 10:41am

Intentional Grounding
 
OSU's Braxton Miller was flagged for intentional grounding trying to avoid a sack Saturday against Miami U. The pass appeared to be backwards.
If it was does that make it either a fumble or a backward pass and a live ball?

BktBallRef Sun Sep 02, 2012 10:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 853073)
If it was does that make it either a fumble or a backward pass and a live ball?

You really don't know if a backwards pass or fumble is a live ball?

Robert Goodman Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:06pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 853073)
OSU's Braxton Miller was flagged for intentional grounding trying to avoid a sack Saturday against Miami U. The pass appeared to be backwards.
If it was does that make it either a fumble or a backward pass and a live ball?

Did an official sound a whistle? If so, it still shouldn't be interntional grounding, but the inadvertent whistle during a backward pass means the passing team can choose to have the down count where the pass originated from -- which if he was trying to avoid a sack is not what they'd choose -- or repeat the down from the previous spot.

JRutledge Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:18pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 853073)
OSU's Braxton Miller was flagged for intentional grounding trying to avoid a sack Saturday against Miami U. The pass appeared to be backwards.
If it was does that make it either a fumble or a backward pass and a live ball?

It is illegal to throw a backward pass to intentionally conserve time.

NCAA 7-2-1. Five Yards from the spot of the foul and lose of down.

By rule it is actually an illegal pass, not IG, but I would not be surprised if that signal was actually used considering the same result and penalty yardage as IG.

Peace

JRutledge Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:32pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robert Goodman (Post 853095)
Did an official sound a whistle? If so, it still shouldn't be interntional grounding, but the inadvertent whistle during a backward pass means the passing team can choose to have the down count where the pass originated from -- which if he was trying to avoid a sack is not what they'd choose -- or repeat the down from the previous spot.

In High School Rules you are correct about the intentional grounding, but in college you are incorrect.

Also this is a spot foul and a loss of down in high school as well not from the previous spot.

Peace

Robert Goodman Mon Sep 03, 2012 02:06pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 853096)
It is illegal to throw a backward pass to intentionally conserve time.

NCAA 7-2-1. Five Yards from the spot of the foul and lose of down.

But that would conserve time, and be illegal, only if it were thrown out of bounds. And then the clock would start on the RFP according to 3-3-2e.15.

JRutledge Mon Sep 03, 2012 02:18pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robert Goodman (Post 853135)
But that would conserve time, and be illegal, only if it were thrown out of bounds. And then the clock would start on the RFP according to 3-3-2e.15.

Agreed but that was not clear in the OP if the ball went out of bounds or not. The ball would be live until it went out of bounds.

Peace

jimpiano Mon Sep 03, 2012 05:05pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 853136)
Agreed but that was not clear in the OP if the ball went out of bounds or not. The ball would be live until it went out of bounds.

Peace

Here is more information

Ohio State at its own37, 2nd and 3, 2:19 left in the second quarter.
Braxton Miller is about to be sacked for a 12 yard loss when he throws a pass which appeared to travel backward. I can't tell you when a whistle blew, but the referee threw his flag. Then he announced a penalty for intentional grounding as a spot foul and loss of down. The play was in the middle of the field.
I am not questioning the referee's judgement and Miami did not argue the decision.

But if, indeed, the ball was thrown backward what would
be the proper call?

mbyron Mon Sep 03, 2012 05:56pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 853143)
But if, indeed, the ball was thrown backward what would
be the proper call?

Backward pass.

JRutledge Mon Sep 03, 2012 06:12pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 853143)
Here is more information

Ohio State at its own37, 2nd and 3, 2:19 left in the second quarter.
Braxton Miller is about to be sacked for a 12 yard loss when he throws a pass which appeared to travel backward. I can't tell you when a whistle blew, but the referee threw his flag. Then he announced a penalty for intentional grounding as a spot foul and loss of down. The play was in the middle of the field.
I am not questioning the referee's judgement and Miami did not argue the decision.

But if, indeed, the ball was thrown backward what would
be the proper call?

Did the ball go out of bounds? And if it was ruled forward and in the middle of the field, that could be IG if the ball never cross the LOS or was thrown in the "tackle box."

Peace

Robert Goodman Mon Sep 03, 2012 07:57pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 853143)
Ohio State at its own37, 2nd and 3, 2:19 left in the second quarter.
Braxton Miller is about to be sacked for a 12 yard loss when he throws a pass which appeared to travel backward. I can't tell you when a whistle blew, but the referee threw his flag. Then he announced a penalty for intentional grounding as a spot foul and loss of down. The play was in the middle of the field.
I am not questioning the referee's judgement and Miami did not argue the decision.

But if, indeed, the ball was thrown backward what would
be the proper call?

Inadvertent whistle. Either that or no call at all, if the whistle was blown after the ordinary termination of the play.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:52am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1