![]() |
Usc
4th and 5 on B's10. Do you think this warranted a USC? See how far away the U was when he called it? What is the down and distance after this play?
Waverly High School Boys Varsity Football - Highlight Videos, Schedule & Roster - Hudl |
1st and 10 for B after the penalty is enforced.
|
I have no idea what it was called for. The official is on the field and knows what has been warned or talked about previously or what player has been warned. His positioning has little to do with this as the official furthest away often is the appropriated person to make the call as they have a better and wider view.
Peace |
Result of the play is first down at the three. Dead ball UC will move ball half the distance. So 1st and goal at the 1.5. Standing over and saying anything other than "I am a registered EMT" to an obviously injured player on the opposite team will likely buy a flag
|
@bigjohn: Why do you think it was USC? The white hat signaled personal foul. :confused:
@radwaste: Why would you penalize B for A's taunt? If A made the line to gain at the B3, then they get a new series. Then enforce USC (if that's what they ended up calling). Then set the chains, 1/10 for A from the B18. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
1st and 10 from 18 |
Quote:
|
Based solely on the clip, I would have a hard time calling that foul from that position. For all I know, he could have been asking the guy is he was alright. Without an accompanying unsportsmanlike gesture (the downward head tilt doesn't count), I wouldn't assume a taunt when another official is standing within hearing distance.
As others have noted though, previous events in the game could change that perspective. |
I do not see a personal foul on this play. The block was legal. If it was a USC for standing over the player, I don't see it unless he said something in which case the 2 other officials should have had a flag. However, without being there, you never really know.
|
I see the big hypocrite is suddenly silent about possible illegal helmet contact since it's his team that created the contact.
He's griped about it for the last 5 years and when it's one of his kids.... chrip...chirp...chirp... go the crickets. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
On the other hand, I only saw the personal foul signal from R. Good block, too bad it took a player down with it. It's almost gotten stylish to wear your helmet so loose that the slightest wallop gets it knocked off. It's like kids think that shows they're playing hard. I wish there was a way to go back and see if their chin straps are actually on right, because there's no way the brain bucket should be popping off if it's secured properly without the snaps coming off, too. |
Quote:
That said, I'm not sure what the personal attack adds to the conversation (and I'm somewhat, but not fully, aware of his posting history). |
Quote:
Peace |
I see no foul, and can't see why U flagged (especially given how late he threw it). That said ... unless R is injured and fighting through it, this guy is the laziest WH I've ever seen - not just during the flagged portion of the video but then dealing with the chains as well and getting back to position. Awful (assuming he's not hurt).
|
I would say that it is very unlikely that this was a foul called on the block action given:
1. The delay in throwing the flag. 2. The fact that he doesn't start jogging until much later, like he saw something else after the play. 3. The fact that he threw the flag straight up in the air instead of at a particular spot. My guess, it was an USC but ref gave wrong signal. |
If IHC was the called, I think the wing should have seen it mostly, but I have no problem with the umpire calling this. But I hate the wings being on the field because the official spends more time retreating then seeing everything in front of them.
Peace |
If this was indeed called a live ball PF, enforcement would be from the A 8yd line (spot of the foul). 4th & 18 for A from the B 23.
If it was a dead ball USC, then it's 1st-and-10 for A from the B 18. |
I have two problems with his post.
First, he's posted play after play after play of hits exactly like this one complaining about IHC not being called. Now that it's called..... incorrectly in my opinion....he complains. Next, this is from his game Friday night. He's got no business posting this. |
OK, now that I have had my hand slapped for reported spam and not posting "reported", let met me finish.
The end result of this play was dead ball USC (they said PF) for taunting even though the R signaled PF. The U called taunting for #4 standing over the down player. It was not even close to being IHC but had the BJ come running in and tossed a flag for that, I would have been ok with it. The kid's helmet came off when he hit the ground and B#4 did not lead with his head or hit A in the head. The status of the ball was 1st and Goal from the 18 after the penalty. I posted this play as well if you watch the orignal again it is the second one. I am sorry if I offend many of you fine gentlemen on this site but you now get to see that I don't make this stuff up. This is the kind of crews we get here in southern Ohia! The R had a bad wheel and couldn't get around. I and the HC begged the LJ for a conference on the down and distance of this play but the guy on our sideline was a replacement supposedly (according to R) and he didn't call anything all night. Anyway, I know none of you guys that come here would do this kind of work. It is just very frustrating that we have this kind of crew do our game. |
Quote:
|
How about the last clip on this highlight? No Call.
Waverly High School Boys Varsity Football - Highlight Videos, Schedule & Roster - Hudl |
Quote:
What was the deal with the chopper? |
No call.
Since last game in old stadium, local ambulance company delivered game ball. I think they plan to drop some coin on the stadium upgrade and wanted some pub. #55 receiving the football is my son. Senior captain. of course we could not use the actual ball they delivered because it hadn't been approved by the U. LOL! Of course this did delay opening kick off about 7 minutes so I guess we were lucky to not get a DOG on first kick off! |
Quote:
|
I think wind was a factor and there was a possiblity of scrubbing the mission.
In the grand scheme of things I don't think 7 minutes was a big deal. :rolleyes: |
Quote:
|
I'm glad John gave all the information...finally. For that dead ball foul (warranted or not) the enforcement was incorrect. It should have been 1st & 10, not 1st & goal. If the foul had occured after the RFP then a 1st & goal would have been correct.
But guys, this points out a problem with many posts. Not getting the information up front to be able to respond to the actual question. Sometimes it's like reading a detective novel and finding out the killer was someone who wasn't even in the story.....:confused: BTW about 20 years ago one of the Seattle tv traffic chopper pilots dropped me the game ball. And yes I caught it!:cool: |
Quote:
A 7 minute delay? Who cares, really? Or, in other words, some people just need to "Lighten up, Francis." |
who cares??
No one did care. I guess the U could have approved the ball as well, we just used one of the other 7 we had already checked in. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:29pm. |