QB goes in motion
Fed Rules:
QB lines up over the center, but does not put his hand underneath. Then, goes in motion parallel to the LOS. The QB does not get set for one sec while the ball is long snapped to the tailback. What do you have? |
Quote:
Peace |
I originally thought this was illegal motion, but after researching the rules/case book I think this is legal in FED rules. The QB can go in motion and does not have to get set for a second or be 5 yards deep at the snap.
7-2-7 ...... Except for the player "under the snapper" a outlined in Article 3, the player in motion shall be at least 5 yards behind his line of scrimmage at the snap if he started from any position not clearly behind the line and did not establish himself as a back by stopping for at least one full second while no par tof his body is breaking hte vertical plane through the wasitline of his nearest teammate who is on the line of scrimmage. 2-32-3 ... A back is any A player who has no part of his body breaking the plane of an imaginary line drawn parallel to he line of scrimmage through the wasit of the nearest teammate who is legally on the line, except for the player under the snapper, who is also considered a back. |
Quote:
If all 11 did not come set prior to the back going in motion, then you would have an illegal shift. 7-2-6 |
Of course the QB can go in motion or shift, that is not the issue. A QB is technically a back and has all the rights of a back. My point was that I am not going to nitpick them being set if they are calling signals or directing their team when their feet or still and would allow some minor movement because they are about likely to receive the snap.
Peace |
Quote:
Being "technically a back" (is there any other way?) is equally irrelevant to this special provision. |
Quote:
Also there is no player definition of a Quarterback under definitions so I was making it clear they have the same rights as any back on the field. It sounded to me that he wanted to not allow them the same rights so "technically" they are a back by rule despite the football slang terminology that we use to describe a player. ;) Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
As for his hands, whether he puts them under cneter or not is immaterial. |
Quote:
Merely posting a true statement does not make you relevant. |
Quote:
Peace |
Canadian Ruling
Quote:
I have nada. Legal play. |
Quote:
And: it happens here only because people post comments in threads that are irrelevant to the OP. New and pertinent: that's the name of the game. So far, you've mastered only 50%. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:21pm. |