Welcome to the real world. Hypothetically speaking, everyone will agree with you by saying that a Referee should not overrule another official's call.

In the real world no referee will knowingly agree to enforce a penalty that he knows is incorrect.

Using the example cited above - Any R who enforces an ineligible down field penalty on a punt will not be working as an R for much longer.

I agree with Walt!:)

But wait, wasn't Walt agreeing with me?:confused:

Brandon, I am not talking about a judgment call, I am talking about a rule error made by a crew mate. I hope you are not suggesting we should not have picked up the flag when I had a real-life rookie line judge had a flag down for an ineligible reciever downfield on a punt. When he reported to me that he had an ineligible downfield on a punt, we had a breif discussion on the field and the flag was waved off. It wasn't changed in an attempt to bury an blatant ruling error, it was picked up because it was a ruling error from the Line Judge plain and simple. I believe my actions fits your description of a white hat overruling another official.

Brandon, I have been officiating for 31 years and that play and the one where the reciever caught the ball, landed on his back, got up, and ran into the endzone and the covering official signalled touchdown (because he wasn't down by contact) are the only two plays that come to mind. By the way, I "Overruled" the second play also, and you would not have wanted to be in that locker room.

It would be a rare occurance to even discuss a judgment call on the field. (We sure do behind closed doors though)

Again Brandon, you wrote a Black and White question and I am giving you an two examples of why your question could be answered with a "Yes"

And walt hit the nail on the head. While hypothetically, we all would like to answer your question with a Yes, its not 100% yes question...

Brandon,

I'm coming into this thread late, but I can give you two times I flat out overruled another official in a varsity game. Both were many years ago and both involved relatively new officials.

The first was a pass play where the QB was under a lot of pressure. I saw the play clearly. I looked up to see the LJ's flag on the field. He told me he had intentional grounding. I said "no, you don't" and waved it off.

The second was a late hit out of bounds called by the BJ in 5-man. The LJ, on whose sideline it happened, went immediately to the BJ, then they both came to me. The LJ said the defender was pushed into the player by an offensive player and the contact was unavoidable, the BJ said he still should have been able to avoid contact. A no-call is just as valid as a call, so I had to pick one. I went with the LJ because he was closer to the play and because I knew the BJ tended to be a bit trigger-happy.

Never say never.