What I Like About the A-11

[Ed Hickland]

Nothing.

In all the threads extolling the virtues of the A-11 and also denigrating it nowhere could I find a critique. So, I did my own.

1) The workload of the umpire is difficult as he must identify the interior linemen who will only be ineligible by position. This would cause ineligible downfield calls to be difficult.

2) Back judge unable to completely view the offensive line would not be able to properly determine if an interior lineman has ventured downfield.

3) The rules as they exist enable officials and defenders to easily identify ineligibility for passing and illegal touching. Imagine, a pass thrown to #88 who was a guard. The opposing coach then complains #88 was ineligible.

There are probably more.

No doubt, the A-11 will be hosed by the Committee, however, hope it does not kill the numbering exception for scrimmage kicks. With the uniform rules it will require some planning to get your long snapper into the game if he happens to be say a tight end.

A-11...R.I.P.