![]() |
Wiffed Free Kick
This would be a case of the wierd but what is the rule?
NFHS Rules. K7 is the kicker for a kickoff. K7 wiffs the kick missing the ball completely. What rule applies? |
Canadian Ruling
Quote:
No call to make. K players can reset. K must still kick the ball before the play clock expires, but there is no foul for offside unless K is past the KL when the ball is kicked. |
Quote:
It's nothing as long as none of the other 10 enter the NZ. But that's not likely to happen. |
Quote:
(Especially if he is the ONLY one to enter, then wouldn't it be a reasonable assumption that this was an intentional act?) |
If the kicker earnestly tried to kick the ball and missed due to slipping or wind or something I'd just blow it dead, provided he didn't contact the ball, and reset everything. If I thought the kicking team was somehow trying to gain an advantage by a 'fake kick' then I'd flag it.
|
Quote:
And no, I don't have any reason to think it's an intentional act. What advantage is gained by having him run up and miss the ball? I've had this happen a couple of times before. And both times, one or more of the other 10 players entered the NZ. Flag. walt, there was no time to kill the play in either situation before K players enter the NZ. |
Quote:
So my original post was somewhat incorrect in that a kicker is not a kicker until he kicks the ball legally. If the potential kicker wiffs the ball more than likely he or a teammate would commit a neutral zone infraction -- dead ball foul. If the wiff is judged to be intentional for some strange reason you could penalize the kicking team with attempting to deceive. Why you would ever believe someone would do this intentionally? |
"Why would you ever believe someone would do this intentionally?"
Ed, Again you forget youth football coaches. :) |
Doing the entire act intentionally I couldn't see, but doing part of it intentionally, setting oneself up to goof, I could see. K1 is supposed to approach the ball and pretend to kick while K2 slightly after him kicks the ball in a different direction. If K1 goes too far selling the fake, he could wind up in the neutral zone before K2 makes contact with the ball. Then you'd want to whistle it dead in Fed or flag it as offside in other codes.
Ever have simultaneous encroachment by both teams in Fed when an onside kick is expected? Not that it would be really simultaneous, but that nobody would be positioned to tell which came first? Robert |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Not all kickers enter the NZ prior to contacting the ball. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
I don't think it's possible for a kicker to miss and not enter the NZ. Encroachment, BJ blows it dead immediately.
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:45pm. |