The Official Forum  

Go Back   The Official Forum > Football

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #1 (permalink)  
Old Fri Oct 17, 2008, 09:23am
Fav theme: Roundball Rock
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Near Dog River (sorta)
Posts: 8,558
'08 NFLN:TA/Official Review Summaries (Upd 15-Oct)

Week 7 Episode Expected 22-Oct-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=
Host: , With: Mike Pereira, Length:
NFLN TA/OR Summary:

My summary:
  • Expected 22-Oct-08
Week 6 Episode Datd 15-Oct-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80baabd1
Host: Rich Eisen, With: Mike Pereira, Length: 7:16
NFLN TA/OR Summary: VP of Officiating Mike Pereira explains three controversial calls from Week 6.
My summary:
  • 0:11 in video - 1st game discussed is Sun 12-Oct-08: PHI 40 @ SF 26, 4Q @ (FGA over upright)
    • Coach can challenge if ball inside uprights, after last year's stanchion play
    • Crew Chief: R 14 Ron Winter
  • 2:12 in video - 2nd game discussed is Sun 12-Oct-08: DAL 24 @ ARI 30, @ (Offside on injured player)
    • MP says inside 2min in a hurry-up, the rule forces B to get their team in proper lineup prior to snap
    • MP says they've never had an option to use a TO to prevent penalty yardage
    • Crew Chief: R 135 Pete Morelli
  • 5:06 in video - 3rd game discussed is Sun 12-Oct-08: DAL 24 @ ARI 30, @ (Romo tuck rule in his EZ)
    • MP says it could be open for further discussion in the off season
    • MP jokes that the tuck rule is the most understood rule now
    • Crew Chief: R 135 Pete Morelli
Week 5 Episode Dated 08-Oct-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80b7a646
Host: Rich Eisen, With: Mike Pereira, Length: 7:02
NFLN TA/OR Summary: Rich Eisen chats with VP of Officiating Mike Pereira about 3 controversial calls from Week 5.
My summary:
  • 0:24 in video - 1st game discussed is Sun 5-Oct-08: CHI 34 @ DET 7, 3Q @ 10:28 (DBC or fumble)
    • DBC is anything other than foot, hand, or ball hitting the ground
    • They see helmet crown hit ground, now have to find ball in player possession
    • MP says that sometimes feeds other than network TV are used
    • Ruled fumble on field, overturned by DET challenge
    • Crew Chief: R 19 Scott Green
  • 3:10 in video - 2nd game discussed is Sun 5-Oct-08: CIN 22 @ DAL 31, 4Q @ 4:38 (Offsetting Facemasks?)
    • MP explains the difference between the open hand and closed fingers on the facemask
    • Good call by covering official
    • Crew Chief: R 127 Bill Leavy
  • 5:20 in video - 3rd game discussed is Sun 5-Oct-08: SD 10 @ MIA 17, 2Q @ 0:47 (Post TD celebration)
    • MP admits that a post-TD celebration wasn't flagged as excessive when it should have been
    • 2+-person groups choreographed spots are fouls
    • Crew Chief: R 65 Walt Coleman
Week 4 Episode Dated 01-Oct-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80b4a351
Host: Rich Eisen, With: Mike Pereira, Length: 6:37
NFLN TA/OR Summary: VP of NFL Officiating Mike Pereira takes a look at some of the tough calls from Week 4.
My summary:
  • 0:16 in video - 1st Game discussed is Sun 28-Sep-08: MIN 17 @ TEN 30, 2Q @ 4:18 (Fwd. Progress)
    • TEN goes "for it" on 4D/1 and MIN coach challenges the spot after calling TO; spot upheld
    • MP says that it is tough to judge fwd progress in the review both in this type of situation
    • Crew Chief: R 135 Pete Morelli
  • 3:09 in video - 2nd Game discussed is Sun 28-Sep-08: ATL 9 @ CAR 24, 1Q @ 13:36 (PF: Helmet to Helmet on QB = RTP)
    • MP wants to move on from the Week 2 Hochuli scenario
    • MP supports the call made on the field by Ed
    • Rich asks if soem fouls can be under review, such as a helmet to helmet
    • MP says that is opens too much up and takes humans out of the equation, and is a slippery slope
    • Crew Chief: R 85 Ed Hochuli
Week 3 Episode Dated 24-Sep-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80b18e47
Host: Rich Eisen, With: Mike Pereira, Length: 4:40
NFLN TA/OR Summary: VP of NFL Officiating Mike Pereira takes a look at some of the tough calls from Week 3.
My summary:
  • 0:16 in video - 1st Game discussed is Sun 21-Sep-08: PIT 6 @ PHI 15, 4Q @ 8:06 (IG in EZ)
    • Roethlisberger's forward pass is knocked down in EZ, flag thrown for IG; was DBC anyways
    • Crew chief is R 66 Walt Anderson
  • 2:26 in video - 2nd Game discussed is Sun 21-Sep-08: DAL 27 @ GB 16, 4Q @ 1:52 (2nd fwd pass)
    • 2nd forward pass from behind the LS thrown
    • MP says Jerry Seeman writes exams and includes this sitch and low and behold - it happens!
    • Crew Chief is R 94 Mike Carey
Week 2 Episode Dated 17-Sep-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80ae6b20
Host: some new guy, With: Mike Pereira, Length: 7:14
NFLN TA/OR Summary: VP of NFL Officiating Mike Pereira looks at some debated calls and non-calls from Week 2.
My summary:
  • 0:11 in video - 1st Game discussed is Sun 14-Sep-08: SD 38 @ DEN 39, 4Q @ 1:14 (Cutler fumble)
    • NFL will look at rule change, with down by contact now reviewable, as a template to beyond DBC to the situation in question
    • MP supports Ed Hochuli and his long-time high-quality NFL service and being a consumate professional
    • Crew Chief R 85 Ed Hochuli
  • 2:22 in video - 2nd Game discussed is Mon 15-Sep-08: PHI 37 @ DAL 41, 4Q @ 1:14 (Early TD celebration)
    • MP notes some similarity with play in 1st game discussed
    • SD/DEN game the Team B recovery was immediate - not so in this game
    • MP says big question is how long do we let players play through a ruling on the field
    • Crew Chief R 77 Terry McAuley
  • 4:02 in video - Next situation discussed is Sun 14-Sep-08: SD 38 @ DEN 39, 1Q @ 11:30 (Replay equipment failure)
    • Chambers' possibly striped of ball by Bailey and after SD challenge, call on field stands, a turnover to DEN, due to failure
    • MP says a computer hard drive failure was the cause, says more intense pre-game equipment testing will be done prior to games
    • Crew Chief R 85 Ed Hochuli
  • 5:50 in video - 3rd game discussed is Sun 14-Sep-08: OAK 23 @ KC 8, 3Q @ 12:33 (Muffed punt)
    • KC punts and first touches ball
    • MP says OAK can risk-free try to recover and return for a TD; if OAK fumbles and KC gains possession, OAK can accept the first touch foul, and re-take ball
    • Crew Chief R 66 Walt Anderson
Week 1 Episode Dated 10-Sep-08 http://www.nfl.com/videos?videoId=09000d5d80ab4f60
Host: Rich Eisen, With: Mike Pereira, Length: 6:14
NFLN TA/OR Summary: VP of NFL Officiating Mike Pereira looks at some debated calls and non-calls from Week 1.
My summary:
  • 0:26 in video - 1st Game discussed is Sun 07-Sep-08: SEA 10 @ BUF 34, 3Q @ 2:27 left (Fake FGA)
    • Mike confirms it's legal to throw to BUF DE 92 who reported as eligible
    • MP's concern is of BUF DE 92 is not part of an substitution package
    • Lingering is UNS and prevents departing or entering substitutes being part of the deceptive aspect of this play
    • MP notes that he doesn't know if BUF DE 92 was part of the substitution package
    • Crew Chief: R 65 Walt Coleman
  • 2:36 in video - 2nd Game discussed is Sun 07-Sep-08: CHI 29 @ IND 13, 2Q @ 4:05 left (Safety Touch)
    • Rich didn't know that the whole ball had to leave the EZ
    • MP mentions that it seems like a contradiction, but obviously it isn't, and logically explains how the whole ball must leave the EZ
    • Challenge issued: call on field upheld
    • Crew Chief: R 132 John Parry
  • 3:52 in video - 3rd Game discussed is Sun 07-Sep-08: DAL 28 @ CLE 10, 2Q @ 9:55 left (Celebration after TD)
    • Owens earns a UNS flag for doing a Usain Bolt imitation after a TD
    • Rich notes that the NFL is accused of standing for No Fun League
    • MP says the rule is to show sportsmanship and team concept as these are paramount as the NFL is emulated by lower levels of football
    • Going to the ground is only permitted to Praise the Lord (MP doesn't wish to be hit by lightning)
    • Crew Chief: R 63 William F. Carollo
__________________
Pope Francis
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
'08 NFLN:TA/Official Review Summaries (Thru Week 3) JugglingReferee Football 0 Wed Sep 24, 2008 10:50pm


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:16pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1