Face mask-pass or no pass...
Friday night, QB is back for a pass. He never threw the ball but it was an apparent pass play to be, if you will. As he is being tackled, his mask gets pulled. WH and U both flagged it and though he was tackled about five yards behind the LOS, they took it to the previous spot and assessed because they thought it was a loose ball play since it was supposed to be a pass play.
I figured it (the assessment) should have been at the end of the run and replay the down but was talked out of it. Opinions appreciated. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Maybe the Fed enforcement is different than yours TX?
|
Canadian Ruling
Quote:
Facemask is a UR foul. We have no 5-yard variety. 15y from PLS, AFD. |
Quote:
|
It all depends if you are playing under NCAA rules or Fed. The codes are different.
|
Quote:
|
FED Ruling - All But One Principle
The basic spot for a running play is the end of the run. This is the 'All' portion of the All-But-One principle. The 'One' is a foul by the offense behind the basic spot. In this case we have a foul by the defensive the occurred behind the basic spot. The spot of enforcement is the basic spot (end of the run). Mark off the yardage and replay the down. |
REPLY: Absolutely a Fed-NCAA rules difference: Previous spot enforcement for NCAA; End-of-run enforcement for Federation.
|
Same scenario: He (QB) gets his masked pulled while running from the defense, behind the LOS, then throws an incomplete pass. Then you have a loose ball play with spot of enforcement being the previous spot? Thanks for your replies. We are talking NF rules in Iowa.
|
Quote:
What part of Iowa buckrog64? I'm from the NW corner of the great state of Iowa. |
Webster City area...
I'll have to recheck with those guys and find out specifically why they went back to the previous spot. We had a similar deal happen last year at a crucial time, and we got that right. So I'm not sure why the intepretation changed this time. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:27am. |