The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   NFHS: Unnumbered field (https://forum.officiating.com/football/38448-nfhs-unnumbered-field.html)

voiceoflg Tue Sep 25, 2007 11:47am

NFHS: Unnumbered field
 
I've broadcast more than 100 NFHS varsity football games and this past Friday was my first on an unnumbered field. There was a logo at the 50, so that helped. But no other numbers. In fact, there were metal signs of numbers usually placed on the fence around the field, but they were stacked neatly on the ground during the game. Is there a rule requiring the field to be numbered? If not, would you be in favor of one?

andy1033 Tue Sep 25, 2007 03:00pm

The field should have numbers. If not send a note to the school. Thats all we can do.

waltjp Tue Sep 25, 2007 03:03pm

If the field is improperly marked we're required to follow-up with a letter to our state association informing them of the problem.

Warrenkicker Tue Sep 25, 2007 03:41pm

This is the only reference in the rules book.

1-2-2 Yard-line markers, constructed of soft, pliable materials, if placed on the ground, should be no closer than 5 yards to the sideline.

That implies that there must be yard-line markers.

I will remember the 5 yards though as I don't think we ever move them that far back. I will bring that up this Friday.

JRutledge Tue Sep 25, 2007 06:15pm

I do not have my books at all, but numbers are not at all required. The rules about illegal substitution that added the 9 yard marks could apply to numbers or a line or "tick mark" in order comply with a legal substitution. The numbers are never required on a field. It is just in recent years that I can pretty much expect numbers on the field. Many fields for years only had lines.

Peace

andy1033 Tue Sep 25, 2007 07:19pm

they are suppose to have a hash mark or numbers per rules.

see 1.2f

Warrenkicker Wed Sep 26, 2007 07:32am

Jeff - no one has said that numbers were required on the field. Numbers painted on every other line have only been a recent thing in my area too. However 1-2-2 says that yard line indicators at least 5 yards out of bounds are required. Thus his statement that the usual signs around the field were neatly stacked and not in their usual locations.

BuckeyeRef Wed Sep 26, 2007 07:52pm

Warrenkicker,

I don't think the rule cited in the post above says that numbers are required on or around the field. If says signs if placed around the field must be placed five yards from the field of play. The word if is an optional word indicating that the signs are optional. If the signs were mandatory, the rule would state that they shall be placed at least five yards from the field of play.

GFD406 Thu Sep 27, 2007 07:18am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warrenkicker
This is the only reference in the rules book.

1-2-2 Yard-line markers, constructed of soft, pliable materials, if placed on the ground, should be no closer than 5 yards to the sideline.

That implies that there must be yard-line markers.

I will remember the 5 yards though as I don't think we ever move them that far back. I will bring that up this Friday.

I move them every week, I dont move them 5 yards because most fields do not have that much room. Seem like every school puts them right. I normally move them to the edge of the team box.

Warrenkicker Thu Sep 27, 2007 08:05am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BuckeyeRef
Warrenkicker,

I don't think the rule cited in the post above says that numbers are required on or around the field. If says signs if placed around the field must be placed five yards from the field of play. The word if is an optional word indicating that the signs are optional. If the signs were mandatory, the rule would state that they shall be placed at least five yards from the field of play.

Nowhere does it say IF there are numbers as I read it.

1-2-2 Yard-line markers, constructed of soft, pliable materials, if placed on the ground, should be no closer than 5 yards to the sideline.

This says to me that there are to be yard-line markers no closer than 5 yards from the sideline and that if they are on the ground they shall be made of soft, pliable materials. This leaves the option for putting signs on a fence. If yard-line markers were optional the rule would say, "Yard-line markers may be used if placed...." just like the rule about an auxiliary line-to-gain marker under 1-3-5c.

1-3-5c Unofficial auxiliary line-to-gain and down indicators may be used on the sideline opposite the official line-to-gain and down indicators, and shall be operated approximately 2 yards outside of the sideline except in stadiums where the total playing enclosure does not permit.

I agree that the use of "should" in 1-2-2 is unusual but your argument about that is should say "shall" if it wasn't optional isn't a good one as the rule for the auxiliary line-to-gain marker uses "shall".

But then again I am not going to make this a huge issue. The numbers have always been there when I needed them.

Warrenkicker Thu Sep 27, 2007 08:11am

Quote:

Originally Posted by GFD406
I move them every week, I dont move them 5 yards because most fields do not have that much room. Seem like every school puts them right. I normally move them to the edge of the team box.

Since the two yard belt around the field is now supposed to be clear of anybody except for the three coaches in the coach's box it is convenient to use the yard markers to indicate the edge of this belt if there isn't a line. I usually move the goal line marker further away as I will get a long way off the field sometimes there. I don't want to be tripping over something there and also don't want to give up the line if the play comes toward the pylon. I will end up 5 yards off the field sometimes to avoid being rolled into by a tackler. The year before I joined my first varsity crew that crew had a wing rolled into at the goal line and he broke his leg.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:50pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1