NFHS Table 7-5
Does anyone else think Table 7-5 in the NFHS Rules Book is incorrect in saying illegal touching is enforced from the basic spot?
|
Quote:
|
The penalty is not always enforced from the basic spot. The penalty for illegal touching behind the previous spot is enforced from the spot of the foul.
|
Quote:
|
Correct. So is the table correct when it says the enforcement spot is the basic spot?
|
Quote:
Articles 2-7 further explains those multiple options. When an Offensive foul alters the standard enforcement spot, doesn't that altered spot become simply a different "basic spot"? |
No, Rule 10-6 clearly distinguishes between the basic spot and the spot of the foul. It doesn't say the basic spot is changed to the spot of the foul.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
NFHS 10-6 explains the "All-but-one" PRINCIPLE. In essence, explains the EXCEPTION "of a foul by the offense which occurs BEHIND the basic spot during a loose ball or running play is "enforced from the spot of the foul." In as much as this EXCEPTION is applied ALWAYS, doesn't that mean it is THE "Basic Spot" ("this is the basic spot for penalty enforcement"- see 10-4-1) WHENEVER the EXCEPTION is applied? |
No. Rule 10-4 goes on to define the various basic spots and rule 10-5 gives us special enforcement rules. These are referenced in 10-6. Table 7-5 is an oversimplification of these rules. The problem is many officials use Table 7-5 as a reference. I think this could be easily remedied by splitting #4 in the table into 2 parts to avoid any confusion. Behind the NZ spot of the foul, in or beyond the NZ previous spot.
|
Basic spot is defined in 2-41-1. 10-4-1 clearly indicates "the basic spot is determined by the action that occurs during the down". 10-4-2 then tells us what the basic spots are.
The table is fine. You can't always read one line or sentence or article in the rule book to come up with a ruling. It may require a definition, a rule, and a fundamental. |
Quote:
2-41-1:"The basic spot is a point of reference for penalty enforcement. "ABO" is a consistent reference for a set of specifically defined penalties. Wouldn't the specific identification for the "point of reference for (THEIR UNIQUE) penalty enforcement be THEIR "basic spot"? |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:03am. |