The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Football (https://forum.officiating.com/football/)
-   -   Ending of Ohio/Minnesota (https://forum.officiating.com/football/100148-ending-ohio-minnesota.html)

bwburke94 Mon Sep 28, 2015 07:30pm

Ending of Ohio/Minnesota
 
College Football Week 4 Wrap: Quack in the Armor « (see "Delay of Something Something" section)

CT1 Tue Sep 29, 2015 08:25am

(smh)

bigjohn Tue Sep 29, 2015 09:42am

Unbelievable!!

jchamp Tue Sep 29, 2015 12:17pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bwburke94 (Post 967229)
College Football Week 4 Wrap: Quack in the Armor « (see "Delay of Something Something" section)

For those not interested in searching through the entire week's recap:
Trailing 27-24 at Minnesota with seven seconds to play, Ohio lined up to attempt a 53-yard field goal to tie. As is custom, Gophers coaches called a timeout just prior to the decisive kick in an attempt to ice Bobcats kicker Josiah Yazdani, who — as is also the custom — nonchalantly followed through with a warm-up kick. But wait!
Yes: In the seconds immediately following a pointless timeout by Minnesota, called with the express purpose to delay the end of the game, an intrepid official called a delay-of-game flag on Ohio because of Yazdani’s unsanctioned kick. Now faced with a 58-yard attempt following the penalty, the Bobcats opted to scrap the field goal altogether and throw up a Hail Mary instead, which fell predictably incomplete. Gophers win, and Ohio coach Frank Solich is left to wonder what the hell just happened:
“The thing that bothers me on that type of play,” Solich said. “Is that the ball gets snapped, so apparently the center doesn’t hear the whistle, either. But somehow you’re expecting the kicker to hear it when he’s concentrating on the snap. The crowd is very, very loud. He’s following through to what, he thinks, is maybe the game-winning kick.”
... [NCAA rules for delay of game snippet]...
Was Yazdani’s kick “deliberately advancing the ball after it is dead”? Was it “clearly designed to delay officials,” even though the officials had just stopped the play in order to delay it? Is there any existing precedent or plausible justification whatsoever for that flag to have been thrown in that situation? I could go on, but before I get flagged for delay of column, I’ll just answer: Nope.

bigjohn Tue Sep 29, 2015 12:38pm

Pure Male Bovine Excrement!!!

:mad:

Dakota Tue Sep 29, 2015 01:04pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jchamp (Post 967305)
For those not interested in searching through the entire week's recap:
Trailing 27-24 at Minnesota with seven seconds to play, Ohio lined up to attempt a 53-yard field goal to tie. As is custom, Gophers coaches called a timeout just prior to the decisive kick in an attempt to ice Bobcats kicker Josiah Yazdani, who — as is also the custom — nonchalantly followed through with a warm-up kick. But wait!
Yes: In the seconds immediately following a pointless timeout by Minnesota, called with the express purpose to delay the end of the game, an intrepid official called a delay-of-game flag on Ohio because of Yazdani’s unsanctioned kick. Now faced with a 58-yard attempt following the penalty, the Bobcats opted to scrap the field goal altogether and throw up a Hail Mary instead, which fell predictably incomplete. Gophers win, and Ohio coach Frank Solich is left to wonder what the hell just happened:
“The thing that bothers me on that type of play,” Solich said. “Is that the ball gets snapped, so apparently the center doesn’t hear the whistle, either. But somehow you’re expecting the kicker to hear it when he’s concentrating on the snap. The crowd is very, very loud. He’s following through to what, he thinks, is maybe the game-winning kick.”
... [NCAA rules for delay of game snippet]...
Was Yazdani’s kick “deliberately advancing the ball after it is dead”? Was it “clearly designed to delay officials,” even though the officials had just stopped the play in order to delay it? Is there any existing precedent or plausible justification whatsoever for that flag to have been thrown in that situation? I could go on, but before I get flagged for delay of column, I’ll just answer: Nope.

From what I was told by someone who actually saw the game on TV, there was a noticeable delay between the whistle and the snap of the ball, so this was not the typical last second timeout where the offense can't stop a play about to start. The offense started the play after the play was whistled dead. Allegedly, anyway. IDK if this matters to the ruling. It is also not shown in the gif-clip attached to the article, since by the actions of the crew, apparently the whistle has already blown.

jchamp Tue Sep 29, 2015 01:56pm

Usually if something is pretty controversial, the recap likes to bring it up. All the recaps I saw were from Big10 Network, who had broadcast rights to the game. They didn't mention anything about the penalty. Just went to the hail mary play.

Altor Tue Sep 29, 2015 02:11pm

Here's an article that shows a little more pre-snap.

Football: Bobcats fall in final seconds to Minnesota – Speakeasy Magazine


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:44am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1