SCalScoreKeeper Got a block/charge video from a state regional final game yesterday I'd like to post. http://www.dailynews.com//sports/20150321/chaminade-girls-basketball-comes-up-short-against-mater-dei-in-regional-final Click on the link Charge or Block? to view IMHO this is a charge a thousand times over.
[deleted] SCalScoreKeeper wroteGot a block/charge video from a state regional final game yesterday I'd like to post. http://www.dailynews.com//sports/20150321/chaminade-girls-basketball-comes-up-short-against-mater-dei-in-regional-final Click on the link Charge or Block? to view IMHO this is a charge a thousand times over. Defender is legal, looks like a charge to me. I prefer my charges to be a little more than that one though, I think I could live with a no call.
SCalScoreKeeper That's what I thought too.Defender legal,not a whole lot of contact but she obtains position.Bunch of fanboys out here trying to stir up trouble saying that should be a block.
[deleted] SCalScoreKeeper wroteThat's what I thought too.Defender legal,not a whole lot of contact but she obtains position.Bunch of fanboys out here trying to stir up trouble saying that should be a block. Just tell 'em "this ain't D1". 😀
Raymond SCalScoreKeeper wroteThat's what I thought too.Defender legal,not a whole lot of contact but she obtains position.Bunch of fanboys out here trying to stir up trouble saying that should be a block. What kind of trouble? Is there a plan to march on CIF headquarters?
[deleted] SCalScoreKeeper wroteThat's what I thought too.Defender legal,not a whole lot of contact but she obtains position.Bunch of fanboys out here trying to stir up trouble saying that should be a block. Where are these fanboys?
[deleted] SCalScoreKeeper wrotehttp://socalhoops.com/ Where can I find the thread where the fanboys are going nuts? Edit: I found the "thread" if you can call it that. Click on "Women's Forum" in the left hand bar and you can see the thread "MD refs". Still trying to figure out how to post/reply, this """forum""" is the worst thing I've ever seen.
SCalScoreKeeper Click on the women's forum then the thread MD refs at the very top and there's another thread in the middle of the page.
Kelvin green Easy charge call. Defender is playing good defense, does nothing wrong and gets knocked to the floor... I think a no call here encourages rough play or retaliation but that's me
BryanV21 Pretty sure I'd call the charge too. The defense did nothing wrong, so it surely is not a block. I could live with a no-call, as there wasn't much contact, but I'm on the side of the official here.
Raymond Rich wroteI don't disagree with the call. I do think it's an awfully fast whistle, though. I was going to post the same thought.
[deleted] Rich wroteI don't disagree with the call. I do think it's an awfully fast whistle, though. I think so too. Whistle looks better when you call it and the defender is on the ground.
Pantherdreams All criteria of a PC are met. If she had no called it I could have lived with that too.