Dunk and Hang on Rim (Video)

APG

Would the hang be enough for you to give a T?

Welpe

Not a chance IMO. He has significant momentum going forward and lets go once that has expended.

[deleted]

No.

JeffM

i wouldn't call a T.

VaTerp

welpe wrote
not a chance imo. He has significant momentum going forward and lets go once that has expended.

Nevadaref

It's 50/50 in my opinion. If a partner whacked him, I would support him.

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

APG wrote

Would the hang be enough for you to give a T?

In a heart beat.

MTD, Sr.

mutantducky

Great play! (no T, but it was close, he seemed to pull himself up a bit)

Camron Rust

Nevadaref wrote
It's 50/50 in my opinion. If a partner whacked him, I would support him.

Agree. He didn't just hang on for momentum but did a bit of a pull-up to go along with it. I've let such actions go and I've called such actions.

Raymond

Nevadaref wrote
It's 50/50 in my opinion. If a partner whacked him, I would support him.

I agree. Can see arguments for both sides.

crosscountry55

BadNewsRef wrote
I agree. Can see arguments for both sides.

I agree, it's close. IMO, not enough for a T. If he does a full chin-up, sure, but during his mini-chin-up, he does look down into his landing area. So I'll give him the benefit of the doubt.

fullor30

Letter of the rule ..... Yes

Spirit of rule ........ No

I wouldn't call it, but agree with Nevada if partner did, I could see rationale

If no defender in vicinity, call might be better supported.

walt

The mini chin up at the end might be enough for the T but could support either way.

JRutledge

Nope.

Peace

bob jenkins

I'd vote "no" on a T here

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

If I were still officiating at the collegiate level, I probably (99%) not call this a TF. BUT!! At the H.S. level this is a video casebook play of a TF for hanging on the rim.

MTD, Sr.

BillyMac

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr. wrote
At the H.S. level this is a video casebook play of a TF for hanging on the rim.

You're just envious because you can't jump high enough to touch the rim any more. How come the players stay the same age, and we keep getting older? It just doesn't seem fair.

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

BillyMac wrote
You're just envious because you can't jump high enough to touch the rim any more. How come the players stay the same age, and we keep getting older? It just doesn't seem fair.

Not only that, they keep getting faster and quicker.

MTD, Sr.

Freddy

Nyet

BillyMac

Freddy wrote
Nyet

Freddy: Please go to your Official Forum Member Profile page, and under "Language", please uncheck "Russian", and check "English".