Throw in spot after the foul

jeremy341a

I had someone tell me at a mechanics clinic last night that the throw in spot following a foul is always at the spot closest to the ball. Per my understanding of 7-5-4 it is nearest the spot of the foul. Is this correct? Is the college rule different?

Freddy

jeremy341a wrote
I had someone tell me at a mechanics clinic last night that the throw in spot following a foul is always at the spot closest to the ball. Per my understanding of 7-5-4 it is nearest the spot of the foul. Is this correct? Is the college rule different?

Was that "someone" a paying customer or a paid clinician?

NFHS: You are correct. Except for after a double personal, double technical or simultaneous foul (cf. 7-5-3b), which would go to spot "nearest where eh ball became dead," thus presumably at the spot closest to the ball.
Will await NCAA expertise on that ruleset.

bob jenkins

NCAA is the same for the garden-variety personal foul.

Raymond

jeremy341a wrote
I had someone tell me at a mechanics clinic last night that the throw in spot following a foul is always at the spot closest to the ball. Per my understanding of 7-5-4 it is nearest the spot of the foul. Is this correct? Is the college rule different?

Often times "someone" is wrong, especially when they can't pull out a book and show you something in writing.

Don't let "someone" cause you to doubt your own reading of the rules.

The_Rookie

BadNewsRef wrote
Often times "someone" is wrong, especially when they can't pull out a book and show you something in writing.

Don't let "someone" cause you to doubt your own reading of the rules.

Plus 100!..Many doubters in the world in which we work🙂

jeremy341a

BadNewsRef wrote
Often times "someone" is wrong, especially when they can't pull out a book and show you something in writing.

Don't let "someone" cause you to doubt your own reading of the rules.

When the presenter tells me one thing even though I read another I have doubt as to whether I am reading it correctly or perhaps missing another important aspect. I feel it that doesn't cause me doubt than perhaps I would not find a mistake I am making.

Raymond

jeremy341a wrote
When the presenter tells me one thing even though I read another I have doubt as to whether I am reading it correctly or perhaps missing another important aspect. I feel it that doesn't cause me doubt than perhaps I would not find a mistake I am making.

If it was the presenter, then you have a lot bigger problem. 😉

Only thing I can think of is that he was speaking about double fouls.

[deleted]

jeremy341a wrote
When the presenter tells me one thing even though I read another I have doubt as to whether I am reading it correctly or perhaps missing another important aspect. I feel it that doesn't cause me doubt than perhaps I would not find a mistake I am making.

Whenever I double take like that I always make sure I understand the situation the presenter is talking about. Usually there is some detail that I missed, rather than the veteran guy being wrong. 🙂

jeremy341a

BadNewsRef wrote
If it was the presenter, then you have a lot bigger problem. 😉

Only thing I can think of is that he was speaking about double fouls.

No after he said it I raised my hand and said on a foul will the ball be taken out at the spot closest the ball or foul and He said "on all fouls it will taken out at the spot closest to the ball.

I was wondering if the college rule was different and that is what caused his confusion.

I didn't press the issue there bc 1. I then had doubts and 2. I'm not being confrontational.

jeremy341a

AremRed wrote
Whenever I double take like that I always make sure I understand the situation the presenter is talking about. Usually there is some detail that I missed, rather than the veteran guy being wrong. 🙂

There wasn't any specific situation other than how the lead and trail move after a foul is called. This was a mechanics clinic that is required to be attended by all officials in their first 3 years.

BillyMac

And while we're at it ...

The penalty for a three second violation is a throw in at the spot closest to the violation, not closest to the ball.

And ...

The penalty for a ten second violation, or a backcourt violation, is not always a throwin at the division line (although it may be), it's nearest the spot of the violation.

Nevadaref

jeremy341a wrote
No after he said it I raised my hand and said on a foul will the ball be taken out at the spot closest the ball or foul and He said "on all fouls it will taken out at the spot closest to the ball.

I was wondering if the college rule was different and that is what caused his confusion.

I didn't press the issue there bc 1. I then had doubts and 2. I'm not being confrontational.

Shameful. People who teach the newbies have to be very precise as newer people will remember the information provided for a long time, including the incorrect stuff.