Good no call? Yay or nay?

JetMetFan

Camron Rust

If you ignore the charge as the lead did, the OOB direction appeared to be correct.

twocentsworth

imho, that's a PC foul.

bainsey

Charge.

canuckrefguy

Camron Rust wrote
If you ignore the charge as the lead did, the OOB direction appeared to be correct.

True. Better to have a whistle on that play, though I think. Good defense gets penalized, there's enough contact, and that guy definitely is not flopping.

I think that's one of those plays where you can have a whistle and never get an argument.

Camron Rust

canuckrefguy wrote
True. Better to have a whistle on that play, though I think. Good defense gets penalized, there's enough contact, and that guy definitely is not flopping.

I think that's one of those plays where you can have a whistle and never get an argument.

Absolutely agree....i was trying to deliver that meaning with some form of literary subtlety and cleverness that has never been my strong suit. (Where's my buddy the writer when I need him?)

canuckrefguy

Camron Rust wrote
Absolutely agree....i was trying to deliver that meaning with some form of literary subtlety and cleverness that has never been my strong suit. (Where's my buddy the writer when I need him?)

lol maybe my literary subtlety radar's a bit weak 😛

JetMetFan

Camron Rust wrote
Absolutely agree....i was trying to deliver that meaning with some form of literary subtlety and cleverness that has never been my strong suit. (Where's my buddy the writer when I need him?)

I understood you, Camron. Though I'm up at 3 AM so my standards may be low 😀

APG

I personally would have had a charge, but it's not the worst no call in the world.

JRutledge

PC foul all the way. I think you cannot pass on that amount of contact and a player falling to the floor.

Peace

Raymond

I can live with that no-call. First contact was with the ball to B1's torso. Can live with a PC also.

NoFussRef

BadNewsRef wrote
I can live with that no-call. First contact was with the ball to B1's torso. Can live with a PC also.

HUH? I would have easy PC here, L took the chicken-way out with OOB.

As a dribbler, am I allowed to bowl through a defender (established LGP) provided I lead with the ball rather than the elbow/forearm seen here?

If so, cite NFHS?

Raymond

NoFussRef wrote
HUH? I would have easy PC here, L took the chicken-way out with OOB.

As a dribbler, am I allowed to bowl through a defender (established LGP) provided I lead with the ball rather than the elbow/forearm seen here?

If so, cite NFHS?

Show me a cite that says knocking someone down with the ball is a foul.

NoFussRef

BadNewsRef wrote
Show me a cite that says knocking someone down with the ball is a foul.

Touche!
Fair enough. (Setting aside intentional/flagrant/USC).

As for OP, I still see PC.

Raymond

NoFussRef wrote
Touche!
Fair enough. (Setting aside intentional/flagrant/USC).

As for OP, I still see PC.

Plus, I said I would have no problem with a PC call either. Just to me the main contact was from the ball hitting B1 which got him off balance.

JugglingReferee

In order, I like these calls:

PC foul
travelling
no call with the OB direction as the L shows

Everything other than that is a wrong call.

Multiple Sports

Agree with BNR (I think that may be twice this year)... I have no issues with a PC, but am leaning towards a NC

Toren

Player control

Why is my slot trying to officiate from the T? He would have had a nice angle if he would have hustled down. Instead he took it easy and put it all on the L. The L passed on it, and the C couldn't come in late because it's so far away. Might as well bought a ticket and sat with the other spectators.

HawkeyeCubP

JetMetFan wrote

Big fat nay. L should be keying in those two defenders, and C looks lazy and can't help.

JugglingReferee

JugglingReferee wrote
In order, I like these calls:

PC foul

travelling

Everything other than that is a wrong call.

I was able to pause the video to see the airborne pivot foot returning to the floor after contact, with ball still in hand. If you're not going with a foul, then giving the ball back to A misses two infractions by A, so I no longer support option 3.

L missed the PC foul, and T missed the travel.