MJT I know it is not a travel to dive for a ball and slide, but what about if as you are sliding you roll from your stomach to your back? We had a player do that in practice today and I don't have my book here to look it up.
[deleted] MJT wroteI know it is not a travel to dive for a ball and slide, but what about if as you are sliding you roll from your stomach to your back? We had a player do that in practice today and I don't have my book here to look it up. See case 4.44.5 Sit B Hard to call without being there, but if he is still truly sliding there is no travel. If he is really "rolling", then he is really no longer sliding and it would be a travel. IMO
[deleted] This came up in a recent clinic we had. We were told that if the player rolls over while still sliding (ie: one continuous motion), it is not a violation. However, once they stop sliding, that's it.
MJT PYRef wroteThis came up in a recent clinic we had. We were told that if the player rolls over while still sliding (ie: one continuous motion), it is not a violation. However, once they stop sliding, that's it. That is what I thought. He was most definitely still sliding as he rolled to his back, and then stopped.
[deleted] MJT wroteThat is what I thought. He was most definitely still sliding as he rolled to his back, and then stopped. This is one of the top 20 misapplied rules in the game. no violation. See the case I cited previously.
Jurassic Referee MJT wroteI know it is not a travel to dive for a ball and slide, but what about if as you are sliding you roll from your stomach to your back? We had a player do that in practice today and I don't have my book here to look it up.If you judge that the momentum of the "slide" caused the player to roll over, then it's legal. If you judge that the player deliberately rolled over to keep the ball away from an opponent or to gain some other advantage, then it's traveling. It's a htbt judgment call iow.
JRutledge Johnny Ringo wrote... and if this happens and you have nothing the gym lets you hear it. And who cares what the gym says anyway? The gym thinks a legal jump stop should be called traveling. Peace
Nevadaref Johnny Ringo wrote... and if this happens and you have nothing the gym lets you hear it. Really? I've never heard anything from the gym itself. 😉 Perhaps I'm not listening properly. 🙂
refnrev Johnny Ringo wrote... and if this happens and you have nothing the gym lets you hear it. _________________________ The "gym" is going to let you have over alot of things. I'm not sure what your point is.