Rule Test Question #77

mdray

rules
5-8-3a
4-35-1a
4-35-3

JRutledge

Originally posted by garote
All right I'm having a brain cramp. A1 is falling out of bounds..can he/she call time out.

Only the NBA has a rule against this.

Peace

Dan_ref

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by garote
All right I'm having a brain cramp. A1 is falling out of bounds..can he/she call time out.

...If A1 doesn't have possession, I'd look to the coach for confirmation before granting. Why in the world call a timeout because a non-possession player is falling out of bounds? If the timing becomse an issue, you can always say he called it in time, but you just hadn't blown the whistle yet.

Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

(Just nitpicking away here is all 🙂

Jurassic Referee

Casebook play 5.8.3SitD(a).

rainmaker

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

Dan_ref

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

More nits: why can't A1, holding the ball, be OOB when requesting TO?

Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by Dan_ref

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

More nits: why can't A1, holding the ball, be OOB when requesting TO?

Legal,if it's a throw-in.Anyone on Team A can.Also OK if ball is at disposal of Team A for a throw-in,too.
Rule 5-8-3(a)
Casebook play 5.8.3SitB or 5.8.3SitD(c).

BktBallRef

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

How do we know A1 is a she? 😉

(Just nitpicking away here is all) 🙂

Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by BktBallRef

Originally posted by rainmaker
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

How do we know A1 is a she?
[/B][/QUOTE]Most of us don't have a problem knowing that,actually.

Some things to look for:long hair,skirts,lipstick,bumps on their sweaters....

If you need any more help,just ask.

Jay R

Originally posted by JRutledge

Originally posted by garote
All right I'm having a brain cramp. A1 is falling out of bounds..can he/she call time out.

Only the NBA has a rule against this.

Peace

And Feeble!

rainmaker

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by Dan_ref

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

More nits: why can't A1, holding the ball, be OOB when requesting TO?

Legal,if it's a throw-in.Anyone on Team A can.Also OK if ball is at disposal of Team A for a throw-in,too.
Rule 5-8-3(a)
Casebook play 5.8.3SitB or 5.8.3SitD(c).

Wow, I am in awe. I just can't think so logically. Is this another estrogen problem?

Nevadaref

Hey Juules!
OR at the disposal of a player from Team A for a free throw! 🙂

Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by Nevadaref
Hey Juules!
OR at the disposal of a player from Team A for a free throw! 🙂

How does that fall in line with a player or team mate calling a TO while they are OOB-which was the nit being discussed? 😕 The one above is just a simple example of a player holding a live ball in bounds.Different nits completely.

[Edited by Jurassic Referee on Oct 9th, 2003 at 04:33 AM]

BktBallRef

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by BktBallRef

Originally posted by rainmaker
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

How do we know A1 is a she?

Most of us don't have a problem knowing that,actually.

Some things to look for:long hair,skirts,lipstick,bumps on their sweaters....

If you need any more help,just ask. [/B][/QUOTE]

Problem is, I can't see her.

Also, you obviously haven't been to a high school lately. 🙁

Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by BktBallRef
[/B]

Problem is, I can't see her.

Also, you obviously haven't been to a high school lately. [/B][/QUOTE]No....but I've been to a Holiday Inn Express!

mick

Originally posted by rainmaker
If A1 doesn't have possession, I'd look to the coach for confirmation before granting. Why in the world call a timeout because a non-possession player is falling out of bounds? If the timing becomse an issue, you can always say he called it in time, but you just hadn't blown the whistle yet.

Jewel,
If the team in possession wants a time out, just call it.
Don't overthink this mechanic. 🙂
mick

Indy_Ref

Originally posted by mick

Originally posted by rainmaker
If A1 doesn't have possession, I'd look to the coach for confirmation before granting. Why in the world call a timeout because a non-possession player is falling out of bounds? If the timing becomse an issue, you can always say he called it in time, but you just hadn't blown the whistle yet.

Jewel,
If the team in possession wants a time out, just call it.
Don't overthink this mechanic. 🙂
mick

Exactly! I took the ORIGINAL post as one that was just looking for a quick true/false response...and my answer turned into a book-long discussion...

not that that's all bad, of course.

Dan_ref

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee

Originally posted by Dan_ref

Originally posted by rainmaker

Originally posted by Dan_ref
Does A1 need to be inbounds to call...err...to request TO?

I'm sure she does, if she has the ball. Without the ball, I'm not sure. Does anyone know a reference for requesting a time-out without the ball, while out of bounds?

More nits: why can't A1, holding the ball, be OOB when requesting TO?

Legal,if it's a throw-in.Anyone on Team A can.Also OK if ball is at disposal of Team A for a throw-in,too.
Rule 5-8-3(a)
Casebook play 5.8.3SitB or 5.8.3SitD(c).

Wow, I am in awe. I just can't think so logically. Is this another estrogen problem?

Not sure who you're in awe of here but I've been told by many coaches that I inspire awe....pssst, hey Chuck, that is what aweful means, aint it?

ChuckElias

Originally posted by Dan_ref
I've been told by many coaches that I inspire awe....pssst, hey Chuck, that is what aweful means, aint it?

Sure, pardner, sure.

rainmaker

Originally posted by mick

Originally posted by rainmaker
If A1 doesn't have possession, I'd look to the coach for confirmation before granting. Why in the world call a timeout because a non-possession player is falling out of bounds? If the timing becomse an issue, you can always say he called it in time, but you just hadn't blown the whistle yet.

Jewel,
If the team in possession wants a time out, just call it.
Don't overthink this mechanic. 🙂
mick

I suppose you're right. I'm used to the level of play where the coach says, "Time out?!? What for?!?! Lindsey, what the heck are you doing?!?!" Trying to be judicious about my response to the player who is committing a very stupid act.