Casebook play - pushing foul on rebounded while shot is in the air

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

Can anyone tell me if there's a casebook play addressing the following situation:

Player a one (A1) attempt to three-point shot. While the shot is in the air, B1 pushes 82 (A2) while jogging for rebounding position. As the try goes through the hoop, the official blows his whistle for the file (foul) on B1. Both teams are in the double bonus.

My partner who had made the call, got a little bit confused and couldn't explain to the coach. So I did. I told the coach that because we were in bonus, that the shot counted, and then the player who got pushed would be shooting two free throws for the double bonus. The coach believed that the other team should just be given the ball back from Outabounds throw in underneath the basket.

Can anyone site for me if there's a kids book play addressing this.?

Your speech-to-text took some liberties with some of the words ! But, I'm pretty sure I figured it out.

You were certainly correct but in just a few moments of searching I have not found a specific case covering the play.

The only singular fouls for which we do not shoot FTs are team control and player control fouls. When the ball is in the air for a try neither team control nor player control exist. Therefor, it is not one of the foul types for which we do not shoot FTs. Head to the FT line.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

Player a one

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Your speech-to-text took some liberties with some of the words !

So that explains it. The text was actually distracting me from answering the question. At first I thought that "kids book" meant the Illustrated Rulebook.

Whistles & Stripes must have a new toy.

[WhistlesAndStripes]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

So that explains it. The text was actually distracting me from answering the question. At first I thought that "kids book" meant the Illustrated Rulebook.

Whistles & Stripes must have a new toy.

Yes, the speech to text definitely did me in. But I'm glad you guys figured it out. I know that we administered it correctly by shooting a free-throw's. I'm just headed down to referee some games where the same coach will be today, I was hoping to have the casebook played a showing. I'll do some digging in the book a little bit once I get there. I'm still driving right now.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

I'm still driving right now.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

Yes, the speech to text definitely did me in. But I'm glad you guys figured it out. I know that we administered it correctly by shooting a free-throw's. I'm just headed down to referee some games where the same coach will be today, I was hoping to have the casebook played a showing. I'll do some digging in the book a little bit once I get there. I'm still driving right now.

Why did he think you shouldn't shoot free throws?

[WhistlesAndStripes]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Made it safely.

Originally Posted by Adam

Why did he think you shouldn't shoot free throws?

He didn't have a particular reason. He just thought it should be the other team's ball for a throw-in. I explained the whole concept about how there was no team control, therefore, you shoot bonus if the foul count warrants it. He was just having a rough night. Or at least his team was. It happened to be his player's 4th foul, and he didn't sub the kid out. When his team got the ball back after the FTs, that same player attempted a shot at the other end of the floor, missed, and then went right through an opponent trying to get to the rebound and sent the opponent right to the floor. Yeah, that was number 5 on said player. Game over for him before halftime. He actually came out for the second half in street clothes to watch the remainder of the game.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

He didn't have a particular reason. He just thought it should be the other team's ball for a throw-in. I explained the whole concept about how there was no team control, therefore, you shoot bonus if the foul count warrants it. He was just having a rough night. Or at least his team was. It happened to be his player's 4th foul, and he didn't sub the kid out. When his team got the ball back after the FTs, that same player attempted a shot at the other end of the floor, missed, and then went right through an opponent trying to get to the rebound and sent the opponent right to the floor. Yeah, that was number 5 on said player. Game over for him before halftime. He actually came out for the second half in street clothes to watch the remainder of the game.

I would have just said, "Coach, we're in the bonus. I don't understand why you don't think we should be shooting. What am I missing?"

Put it on him to explain why you shouldn't be shooting.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by Adam

I would have just said, "Coach, we're in the bonus. I don't understand why you don't think we should be shooting. What am I missing?"

Put it on him to explain why you shouldn't be shooting.

Some coaches just think that multiple bad things can't happen at once, especially not to their team. Earlier this year, BV, 3 point shot in the air, A1 shoves B1 underneath. Shot is good. A's ball. Coach B was incredulous. "No way do they get the basket and the ball!" This coach was significantly younger than I am, but certainly old enough to know better than this.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

... that was number 5 on said player. Game over for him before halftime. He actually came out for the second half in street clothes to watch the remainder of the game.

Odd, and odd again.

Player with four fouls, still in the game, in the first half (even three is pushing the envelope, especially early in the second period).

Player changing into street clothes, during halftime, because he was disqualified (I have, literally, never observed this, thirty-four years, and counting).

Was this game played in Bizarro World? It is certainly a different brand of basketball compared to what we play here in Connecticut.