NBA blarge (Video)

mutantducky

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SvUexkeSv0A

Jefferson with a huge slam, ref underneath calls a block but ref up top called a charge. That is a block or a no-call. I like the reactions of the bench at 10-11 seconds and the fan in the back. 😮

APG

First, this is a play that the officials could get together and discuss...and come to a single conclusion because the player involves the RA...not that it matters because this isn't an RA play...the defender alights, therefore the RA isn't in play. So if the lead was calling something solely due to the RA, the slot official could come to him.

Even so, I don't think the slot is calling a charge on the offensive player but a clear out with the left hand. As such...this is NOT a blarge...but an offensive foul versus a block...of which they could come together and decide what to do.

Rob1968

APG wrote
First, this is a play that the officials could get together and discuss...and come to a single conclusion because the player involves the RA...not that it matters because this isn't an RA play...the defender alights, therefore the RA isn't in play.

Even so, I don't think the slot is calling a charge on the offensive player but a clear out with the left hand. As such...this is NOT a blarge...but an offensive foul versus a block...of which they could come together and decide what to do.

And, it appears that the Lead didn't finish the block call, but gave up the entire call to the Slot.

Camron Rust

APG wrote
Even so, I don't think the slot is calling a charge on the offensive player but a clear out with the left hand. As such...this is NOT a blarge...but an offensive foul versus a block...of which they could come together and decide what to do.

Agree, that is what he was calling.

Archie Lib

APG wrote
First, this is a play that the officials could get together and discuss...and come to a single conclusion because the player involves the RA...not that it matters because this isn't an RA play...the defender alights, therefore the RA isn't in play.

Newbie here. What's an "RA"?

APG

Archie Lib wrote
Newbie here. What's an "RA"?

The restricted area...area inside the 4 foot (NBA...3 foot in NCAA) semi circle underneath the basket.

mutantducky

incorrect call whatever it is. I don't think I've seen the NBA refs come together on a call like that but I would have liked to seen the other ref come in and say, "I got a block before your clear out with the arm"

APG

mutantducky wrote
incorrect call whatever it is. I don't think I've seen the NBA refs come together on a call like that but I would have liked to seen the other ref come in and say, "I got a block before your clear out with the arm"

What did the defender do wrong? If you want to advocate a no-call, I could live with that...but the defender does nothing illegal in the play above.

Even so, this is not a blarge.

[deleted]

APG wrote
What did the defender do wrong?

He was in the way of a highlight dunk.

APG

AremRed wrote
He was in the way of a highlight dunk.

I always forget that part of the rule book. 😉

zm1283

mutantducky wrote
incorrect call whatever it is. I don't think I've seen the NBA refs come together on a call like that but I would have liked to seen the other ref come in and say, "I got a block before your clear out with the arm"

Do you ever get tired of consistently being wrong on here?

twocentsworth

This call is wrong on several levels:
1) it's NOT an offensive foul.
2) the wrong official makes the call.
3) the slot official uses poor mechanics.

This is DEFINITELY a play that will/did make the video bulletins of the entire NBA staff of how NOT to handle this situation.....

Camron Rust

twocentsworth wrote
This call is wrong on several levels:
1) it's NOT an offensive foul.
2) the wrong official makes the call.
3) the slot official uses poor mechanics.

This is DEFINITELY a play that will/did make the video bulletins of the entire NBA staff of how NOT to handle this situation.....

Disagree...he clearly cleared out the defender's arms with his off arm. That was an excellent call.

mutantducky

it is a horrible call.

and yes...if it was Lebron or Durant it never would have been called. 😀
high five for the NBA

you are right twocentsworth. I would have liked the lead to step in more and make the call. They should review this one because it was confusing what the call was after the play. It should have been a no-call. No way is that offensive. Not even remotely close. I don't even think the calling ref noticed the arm.

jeremy341a

What about what Jefferson does with his off arm to ward off the defender? This is a great call.

Raymond

mutantducky wrote
it is a horrible call.

and yes...if it was Lebron or Durant it never would have been called. 😀
high five for the NBA

you are right twocentsworth. I would have liked the lead to step in more and make the call. They should review this one because it was confusing what the call was after the play. It should have been a no-call. No way is that offensive. Not even remotely close. I don't even think the calling ref noticed the arm.

Because you've gone through NBA training and know their points of emphasis?

constable

twocentsworth wrote
This call is wrong on several levels:
1) it's NOT an offensive foul.
2) the wrong official makes the call.
3) the slot official uses poor mechanics.

This is DEFINITELY a play that will/did make the video bulletins of the entire NBA staff of how NOT to handle this situation.....

1.I don't know if I'd call it, but I have no problem with the offensive call as long as it is for the clear out.

2. Wrong. That's a call that has to come from the slot. That's why there are 3 officials.

3. What's wrong with the mechanics?

Adam

constable wrote
1.I don't know if I'd call it, but I have no problem with the offensive call as long as it is for the clear out.

2. Wrong. That's a call that has to come from the slot. That's why there are 3 officials.

3. What's wrong with the mechanics?

Fast break on weak side, this is C's call first anyway, especially on contact made away from the lead's line of sight.