Quote:
One mistake does not justify another. But one mistake often leads to another. There are any number of reason why the basket may not have counted in the OP. (the foul was before the try...traveling after the foul, etc.) Any one of them could have been a mistake. The failure to signal the basket good and put it on the board is no different than any other mistake. TWO SHOTS |
C and T botched the play...table personnel could have saved them
The C and the T botched the play by not observing and communicating that the basket was good.
Score the basket on the initial field goal. The first (of one) free throw was missed with neither team rebounding like they normally would. So, go to the AP. Both coaches may be upset with the officiating crew. That said, any of the coaches, assistant coaches, table personnel could have seen that the reporting official incorrectly did not count the basket and signaled for two shots. |
Quote:
In the Op the whistle is blown at a time when the error of not counting the basket is still correctable. At the time the referee announced two shots he was correct. no goal had been scored. But once correction made, now it is counted. Turns out only one free throw was merited. It was shot but only one team attempted to rebound. Go to case play as nevada and mtd say. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
There were a lot of mistakes that's for sure. Correctable errors are bad.... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
In this OP, the rules could consider the rebound and put back "play." The game is stopped in time to correct the original error of not counting the goal. score that basket. Now it turns out that A1 is only entitled to the one free throw he just shot. Under regular CE rules you would also score the put back by A2 because points scored before recognizing the failure to count basket/error count. (the referees counted A2 put back, i think) But the administering official told them 2 shots...he was right when he said it but it ended up wrong and team B was prejudiced by it. they didnt rebound. The case play prevents all this from happening. As Nevada pointed out yesterday. Cancel A2 goal and go to arrow. When it happens quick like this and only one team rebounds and you stop it, I think you can say it really isnt "play" and get to the same place. fix error and go to arrow. But, if both teams would have attempted to rebound, A2 gets it and scores, I believe that would clearly be "play." When the game is stopped you would count the original field goal. Count A2 put back and B gets end line throw in. Moral in this mess. Pay attention...always.... |
Do you normally blow the whistle when one player steps in and grabs the ball off a missed FT when more are to follow? I don't. Pretty sure none of us would do anything until he threw the ball through the hoop.
Waive it off, the ball was dead, go AP. We are completely overthinking this thing. |
Quote:
If s/he's "just catching the ball", then no -- but I usually get in there first. If s/he's "rebounding" the ball, then I'm talking to him/her as it's happening and as I'm walking in (and trying not to get hit). If I'm T or C, in the second part above, then I do blow the whistle. |
Quote:
When no one reacts like this accept the one player you can get the right result pretty easily. But, the statement was made that it would not matter how many players tried to rebound the ball because the ball was dead the moment it was missed. When you are dealing with errors/ommisisons that isn't necessarily true. If everybody tries to rebound this missed FT, A2 gets it, puts it back in, then referee puts a whistle on it and figures out they didn't count the original score, it is still correctable. The put back basket by A2 counts and B gets throw in on end line. you would not under the rules waive off that basket and go to the arrow. Correctable errors do make me over think. I won't argue that... |
Quote:
If no basket was scored and two free throws are announced, I'll say it again. As soon as the shot is missed, the ball is dead. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:30pm. |