Miami at Duke (FF1 or Shooting Foul) (Video)

[JRutledge]

9:14 in the second half.

Play from behind and shooter falls hard.

Peace

[frezer11]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

9:14 in the second half.

Play from behind and shooter falls hard.

Peace

I think they did the right thing, pretty minimal contact, if any. He just happened to fall awkwardly. The announcer made it sound a lot worse than it was

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by frezer11

i think they did the right thing, pretty minimal contact, if any. He just happened to fall awkwardly. The announcer made it sound a lot worse than it was

+1

[jeremy341a]

Originally Posted by frezer11

I think they did the right thing, pretty minimal contact, if any. He just happened to fall awkwardly. The announcer made it sound a lot worse than it was

I agree he was pleading for a F1. The replay showed that to be false. I think if they were allowed they would have erased the foul as I don't believe there was contact. If there was contact it was minuscule.

[APG]

Originally Posted by jeremy341a

I agree he was pleading for a F1. The replay showed that to be false. I think if they were allowed they would have erased the foul as I don't believe there was contact. If there was contact it was minuscule.

Not saying it was a foul or not...for an airborne player in this situation, sometimes "miniscule" contact is all that is needed to put a player in this situation off balance.

Anyhow, here's the play:

F1, not playing the ball.

[Camron Rust]

Foul...no upgrade. Didn't even try to foul the guy....tried to avoid him but got unlucky and clipped his foot.

[Raymond]

I would have an FF1 initially, but downgrade after review.

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I would have an FF1 initially, but downgrade after review.

Can you do that? I thought you could downgrade a F2 to an F1, but not F1 to non-flagrant...

But it has been a few years since I read that part of the NCAA M/W rulebooks.

[walt]

NCAAW (voluntary use of monitor):

1. After a call has been made, determine if a flagrant 2 personal foul, flagrant 2 contact technical foul, flagrant 1 personal foul or a contact dead ball technical foul occurred. When it is determined that a flagrant 2 personal or flagrant 2 contact technical foul did not occur but a flagrant 1 personal foul or contact dead ball technical foul or common foul did occur, those fouls shall be penalized accordingly. However, no other infractions may be penalized. When the review discloses, by indisputable evidence, that there was no contact, the foul call shall be reversed with no foul charged.

a. When there is a foul called for contact, the officials, with a plausible reason, may review the severity of that foul during the dead ball period following the call. When the ball becomes live, there shall be no review of the made call.