Tenn vs Michigan (Video)

Nevadaref

6:57 of 1st half verticality play: a blocking foul is called on Michigan defender. What does he do wrong? Excellent TV reply too!
6:45 of 1st half Michigan player throws the ball off the backboard deliberately so that he can go get it again. Would love for the NCAA to put this in the rules video for next season and end the debate.

Nevadaref

Huge block/charge crash at 7:02 of the 2nd half.

Nevadaref

28.6 secs left and the crew goes to the monitor for an OOB call and gets it wrong!

bballref3966

No problem with the player-control foul on Tennessee with 6.0 left.

Freddy

Nevadaref wrote
Huge block/charge crash at 7:02 of the 2nd half.

Seemed an equally huge charge with 6.0 seconds left. Looked like a good call from my LazyBoy.

Nevadaref

I don't like the PC call. Only contact was with the legs and lower body.
Tough angle for Dave Hall. He couldn't see the left shoulder of the offensive player.

Another monitor review for OOB with 2.9 secs left.

JRutledge

I have no problem with the PC call. Threw his shoulder and body into a legal defender. And even IMO and embellishment, but you still should call if the contact is there. The contact was there.

Peace

MechanicGuy

I think the crew had a rough game all around. I thought two of the foul calls on Maymon (2nd and 4th...one of which the OP may be questioning), and they might have blown two different OOB video reviews.

The "big" PC at the end could've gone either way.

And FWIW, the ball stayed in bounds...so if the options are PC or no-call, the PC helped Tennessee.

Nevadaref

MechanicGuy wrote
I think the crew had a rough game all around. I thought two of the foul calls on Maymon (2nd and 4th...one of which the OP may be questioning),

The 4th foul on Maymon was harsh. Big man moving and contact is made with his chest.

MechanicGuy wrote
and they might have blown two different OOB video reviews.

Got the first one wrong, got the second one right.

Larks

Nevadaref

Someone posting worse video than jeremy!

Larks

Eh, its been a while between posts....

Raymond

Nevadaref wrote
Someone posting worse video than jeremy!

And as bad as jump stop.

Larks

wow...when I started here, video wasnt even possible....my bad

#spoiled

zm1283

Thought the PC at the end was a flop.

bballref3966

zm1283 wrote
Thought the PC at the end was a flop.

He may have embellished a little, but there was still contact. The mere fact that a player flops does not mean a foul/contact has not occurred. Clearly there was contact and in David Hall's judgment, the contact displaced the legal defender enough to call a foul.

No problem with this call, also wouldn't have had a problem with a no-call.

APG

Nevadaref wrote
6:57 of 1st half verticality play: a blocking foul is called on Michigan defender. What does he do wrong? Excellent TV reply too!
6:45 of 1st half Michigan player throws the ball off the backboard deliberately so that he can go get it again. Would love for the NCAA to put this in the rules video for next season and end the debate.

Nevadaref wrote
Huge block/charge crash at 7:02 of the 2nd half.

bballref3966 wrote
No problem with the player-control foul on Tennessee with 6.0 left.

Camron Rust

Agree with Nevada on the first one...defender looked entirely legal to me.

No problem with the backboard no call.

Not sure what the defender did wrong in the other block/charge. He got into the path before upward motion, well outside the RA. ???

Good charge call at the end.

[deleted]

Play 1: Nothing

Play 2: Cool

Play 3: Charge

Play 4: Charge

BillyMac

Nevadaref wrote
Would love for the NCAA to put this in the rules video for next season and end the debate.

I would also love the NFHS to follow suit.

But, if they did, what would we argue about every year? We would have to come up with a new annual debatable topic. The off the backboard debate is a classic. I don't think that anything could replace that annual debate.

It's worth another look:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RF3VcagfoZg

Yeah, some of these plays can be considered a try, but not this one. No way. No how. Not this one. Not in my game.