E-mail to the top

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by AremRed

Interesting cuz she never directly addresses what to do when conflicting signals are given before the refs get together, but then says this:

Originally Posted by Rich

Congrats on not asking the right question.

The question must include conflicting preliminary signals at the time the foul is whistled.

The reason I didn't mention conflicting signals is because I didn't want to taint the original answer. Signals are not a part of this case play, which is the main thing I have stood by since day one. If we should/must do a certain thing because of conflicting signals, that's fine. But there is no way one can draw that conclusion by reading this case play.

Don't panic. A follow up question is in the works about conflicting signals.