Video request: Block/Charge BYU at St. Mary's 5:45 remaining in first half.
 

When someone is able to post the video clip, we can debate the proper call.

video added
 

Here's the play...


<iframe width="853" height="480" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/tPIjQ4E75Ck?rel=0" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Is the new college POE to do away with the PC foul??

Get out your credit cards.

They should've left the block/charge rules alone. I'm still failing to see what the problem was that this "solution" was supposed to address.

I had written this play down for further review but I think I got distracted washing baby bottles or something.

I'm shippin' up to Boston...

While watching the game, I thought that it was an obvious player control foul. Seeing the replay verifies that. The defender could not have done better.

Thanks for posting the video for everyone on the forum. The video aspect that a couple of our posters have added to this site in the past couple of seasons has greatly increased the educational value here. Great work, guys!

Travel? :rolleyes: :eek:

Wow.....that is a charge all the way.

Peace

Charge it

So, are some officials judging the "upward motion/movement" of a ballhandler by the movement of the hands and ball, while others are judging the upward moition/movement by watching the feet of the ballhandler? The more I see such calls, the greater the inconsistencies seem to be, from call to call . . .

BTW, I agree with a PC on this one.

On behalf of the video providers, you're welcome. :)

Question for the NCAAM officials in the group. What sort of feedback have you been getting on Arbiter's Central Hub about the block/charge calls with the new guidelines? I've been curious about what the powers that be have been saying.

I do not think the rule has been well defined. I think if anything it has been very inconsistently applied because of that lack of definition or clarification of that definition. This was a stupid rule and was more reactionary to the media than coming up with a solid reasoning for this rule to be changed.

Peace

When in doubt, call a block.

That is fine, but there shouldn't have even been even the smallest doubt on this one.