Video request: Block/Charge BYU at St. Mary's 5:45 remaining in first half.

[JRutledge]

This should have been easy.

Peace

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

That is fine, but there shouldn't have even been even the smallest doubt on this one.

Agreed. I try to bring up these type of plays in my college pre-games to point out that it is still possible for defenders to draw charges from airborne shooters.

I personally feel way too many blocks have been called this season.

[johnny d]

By making it so officials call 80% or more of these plays blocks, the powers that be have begun the process of getting teams to realize there is no benefit to playing defense that close to the basket. Scoring and viewership will rise, and everybody will be happy. Maybe, BNR, you did not get that memo!

[Toren]

Primary defenders drawing charges = same as years before

Secondary defenders drawing charges = way down

Learn to block shots or get out of the way.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Toren

Primary defenders drawing charges = same as years before

Secondary defenders drawing charges = way down

Can't agree with that. I've seen primary defenders get called for a lot more blocks as well.

Originally Posted by Toren

Learn to block shots or get out of the way.

Huh? Isn't the essence of defense preventing the opponent from going where they want to go?

[onetime1]

It looks like the offensive player just runs right over the defense. I would go PC on this play.

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by Toren

Learn to block shots or get out of the way.

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Huh? Isn't the essence of defense preventing the opponent from going where they want to go?

Camron, I agree with you but Toren isn't far off based on some of the calls we've seen/posted. It reminds me of a comment attributed to Calipari at the start of the season. He apparently told his kids if they don't block the shot just get out of the way.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Toren

Learn to block shots or get out of the way.

Which is, frankly, a stupid concept for defense. Most defenders are taught to keep their feet and get into a position to box out (talented shot blockers are the exception, not the rule). Jumpy would-be-shot-blockers are the first guys to get out of position in the paint.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Toren

Primary defenders drawing charges = same as years before

Secondary defenders drawing charges = way down

Learn to block shots or get out of the way.

I can only hope that this changes. Again.

[zm1283]

The NCAA needs to change the rule back to what it was before. They probably won't do that, but they need to. There is more inconsistency now than ever before on these plays, and it's their own fault.

I've learned that the NCAA can't just leave well enough alone and they have to constantly tinker with things that aren't broken.

[ballgame99]

Wow. As a basketball official you don't get PCs handed to you on a platter very often. That was one of them.

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by zm1283

The NCAA needs to change the rule back to what it was before. They probably won't do that, but they need to. There is more inconsistency now than ever before on these plays, and it's their own fault.

I've learned that the NCAA can't just leave well enough alone and they have to constantly tinker with things that aren't broken.

First, it's NCAAM. Don't blame my side for this

Second, I think the worst part of the rule change is it has otherwise capable officials thinking too much. I worked Part I of an NCAAW/NCAAM DH over the weekend. The officials for the men's game were in a serious discussion about plays like this as they headed out to the court. It was more of a panicked discussion like, "I'm not sure how to call these things." That's not a good feeling in mid-February.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by zm1283

I've learned that the NCAA can't just leave well enough alone and they have to constantly tinker with things that aren't broken.

They do this in football, too.

At times NFHS is too slow to change and I think the NCAA embraces change just for the sake of change.

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by Welpe

They do this in football, too.

At times NFHS is too slow to change and I think the NCAA embraces change just for the sake of change.

I figured they probably did.

It seems like they change more mechanics back and forth in baseball than rules. They have switched mechanics one year then gone back to the old way several times recently with no explanation....just because.

[rockyroad]

This play really isn't even a "rule discussion" type of play. The new rule wording really shouldn't have even come into play here. This is a really easy PC call, and I cannot think of any reason why this official went block (other than the fact that we all blow a call every now and then).