Stanford-California Video Request (Video)
APG or Jet or whoever has the ability...
Could you please post the throw-in and subsequent foul at about the 1:56 mark of the second half? Anyone have an offensive foul before the called foul? The defensive foul led to a monitor review to determine whether they should upgrade or not. They stayed with the personal foul and did not upgrade. |
Some of you may be able to browse to the play here: ESPN3 -- Stanford vs. California
|
Should have called the offensive foul. Everything else after that seemed correct and well handled. I will say that the offensive foul did not seem as bad as the defensive player made it look. However, getting that call prevents the rest.
|
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="//www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/UpLwJTrMgbE" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
|
Wow...even I would call that offensive foul. Did the defender embelish...sure, but don't most of them?
|
That looks like a lot of embellishment. I think I would have passed on the PC foul too.
Peace |
No PC. Nice acting job by the defender. The offensive player touched the defender but most certainly didn't displace him.
|
No call on the pc, IMO.
|
This is one of times when a defender oversells a possible PC foul, and it ends up costing him.
|
Quote:
|
These two teams have a recent history of bad blood. Given that I would be inclined to call the PC foul to prevent things from escalating, even though I think the contact is minimal, the defensive player clearly embellished the severity of the contact, and in most situations I would have a no call. I guess you would say my PC call would be game specific, not necessarily play specific.
|
No PC foul for me either.
|
Quote:
|
I have a PC, especially given the back story of their rivalry. The defender didn't do anything wrong/illegal on the initial contact and embellishing doesn't mean no foul was committed. If A1 is enough of a knucklehead to drop a shoulder into someone in that situation (+12, < 2:00) he deserves what he gets.
|
If such a thing was a POE, this is a great time to whip out the PC/T-for-embellishing double foul.
Think of the great calls made in the NHL where a penalty is called, along with a second one for diving. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:42pm. |