Iowa State/Baylor - Video request x2 (Clips Added)

[stiffler3492]

Originally Posted by zm1283

1. About the 57 second mark in the first half. Called a block against ISU and the basket counted.

2. 15:27 mark in second half. Dunk by ISU player with a technical to follow.


Thanks.

About #2...I've seen much more blatant let go.

You can browse the video here.

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by stiffler3492

About #2...I've seen much more blatant let go.

Kind of what I was thinking.

On the block/charge: This play is why I hate the new rule. The officials default to a block on anything close and it really punishes the defense. I think this play was a charge even under the new rules.

[Raymond]

I have a PC on the first play, defender was there before A1 even got the ball.

And I'm passing on the hanging on the rim T.

IMHO

[Lcubed48]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I have a PC on the first play, defender was there before A1 even got the ball.

And I'm passing on the hanging on the rim T.

IMHO

I agree with BNR on both plays.

Also, I thought that the 2 remaining officials did a commendable job in the portions that I watched. I especially liked how the L moved to get an angle on post play with the ball, and then would rotate back. I did that a couple of times last night in myself.

[APG]

[Camron Rust]

#1 close but by the NCAA's new standards, he was certainly not there in time. He was still shifting to his left as the shooter was leaving the court. He only stopped moving left just after the shooter jump. It wasn't by much but it was there. This would even be a block in HS.

#2. I'm passing on that one.

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

#1 close but by the NCAA's new standards, he was certainly not there in time. He was still shifting to his left as the shooter was leaving the court. He only stopped moving left just after the shooter jump. It wasn't by much but it was there. This would even be a block in HS.

#2. I'm passing on that one.

Another example of how good officials can see the same action and disagree on the proper decisions. I have great respect for Camron, but my thoughts are as follows:

1. NFHS that's a PC. He has obtained ILGP prior to both feet of the offensive player leaving the court. NCAA it's super close. Given the new standard and how the instruction has been to call more blocking fouls, I would lean that way. I also believe that the contact being only on the left side of the defender's torso probably unduly influences the decision as it gives the impression that the defender was late in getting to his required spot.

2. The player clearly decided to hang around an extra second with no one under him. The official enforced the rule exactly as written. Unfortunately, this is not the norm and people aren't used to seeing this call made except in extreme situations. I put the T in the "correct call" column.