Too Early in the Lane
Thoughts….
Should NFHS make entering the lane too early on free throws a POE or change the rule to allow players to enter the lane on the release? This seems (at least in GA) to be a growing problem that is not equitably enforced. I think this should be a POE and more strictly enforced…But maybe I'm old school…. :confused: |
I definitely prefer the college rule.
|
What's Next?
Quote:
It's a local POE here after one prominent game last year was won by 3 points by the team which clearly violated this rule 13 -- yes, 13! -- times. The advantage was so stark on video that the only excuse any rational person could come up with was sheer indifference on the part of the one official who, as lead, kept watching the flight of the free throw and missed 10 violations on that team himself, 7 with clear possession consequence for the violating player. Should we abolish the rule for the sake of inattentiveness or indifference? My answer to that question is, what's next after that? It perhaps isn't the best policy to go abolishing rules for the sake of those who don't care to enforce them. Pregame it. Do it. The players will conform. Off my soapbox now. |
Quote:
One relatively recent example is that leaving the court is a violation, where it used to be a technical foul. Many of us believed the "T" was too harsh a penalty, so it wasn't enforced as often as it should have been. I agree we should enforce the lane violations rule as it is, but there's no harm in talking about whether the release vs. ring contact is better for the game. I also prefer the former, but until the NFHS agrees, I'll call the early entry as it was agreed. |
Quote:
We have no problem enforcing it here. I have to ask refiator, though, just how early are they entering? |
It has gone back and forth over the years, and is discussed almost every year (at least for the years that I saw the meeting summaries).
If it's an issue in GA, then have the GAHSA (or whatever it is called) put up a copuple of videos and have the videos affect the post-season assignements for a couple of officials. That will get everyone on board quickly. |
Eventually The NFHS Gets The Point, Sometimes ...
Quote:
|
What Goes Around ...
Quote:
|
I think the rule should go back to being on the release. It think the rational for changing the rule was always stupid to begin with. And it would allow all levels to be similar so that we do not have to split hairs on if a violation took place. A POE is not going to change that fact IMO.
Peace |
You still have to "split hairs" because the players still try to "cheat" and enter just before the ball is released.
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
The other rationale was the purported impact on rebounding. The committee seems to also look for a certain balance between offensive and defensive rebounds. They seem to like the current stats.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I don't think the rule is going to change. Rough play is an ongoing POE. If you allow players to enter on the release then you get a lot of totally unnecessary rough play on made FTs. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:53am. |