Vid request Charlotte and Michigan final sequence (Clip Added)

[Camron Rust]

I've got nothing on these. The defender touched his arm after the shot was away. That is incidental.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by just another ref

And guess what else it is. That's right. A travel. They're everywhere.

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

I've got nothing on these. The defender touched his arm after the shot was away. That is incidental.

Agreed.

[OKREF]

I think the last 2 or 3 times Michigan drove there were travels.

[JRutledge]

Why am I not surprised someone mentioned a travel.

BTW, I think there was nothing to call on this last play.

Peace

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

Why am I not surprised someone mentioned a travel.

Because, like it or not, he did

I can live with the no-call on the initial shot though it wouldn't have surprised me if there had been a whistle. If it had been a no-call the entire game that would've been a lousy spot to have a foul.

[Adam]

I saw the travel on this. Not sure I would have seen it from the floor, but on video it jumped out at me.

As for the contact, all incidental.

[zm1283]

I felt like it was a travel watching it live. I'm not convinced that many of us would have picked it up live though on the court.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Adam

I saw the travel on this. Not sure I would have seen it from the floor, but on video it jumped out at me.

As for the contact, all incidental.

Yes, it was indeed a travel. But, like you, not sure how many would catch it live. I don't think I would have. Some non-basketball officials might even argue that it wasn't even a travel at all.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Adam

I saw the travel on this. Not sure I would have seen it from the floor, but on video it jumped out at me.

As for the contact, all incidental.

I do not see much of a travel. I see a player that is catching the ball with their feet moving. That does not make it a travel IMO. And if you have to look at slow motion replay to determine something, it probably is not as obvious and should not be called.

Peace

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I do not see much of a travel. I see a player that is catching the ball with their feet moving. That does not make it a travel IMO. And if you have to look at slow motion replay to determine something, it probably is not as obvious and should not be called.

Peace

Had this discussion concerning palming in my game Saturday. Team from NYC was playing the local team. Home coach constantly asking for us to call a carry. Our halftime discussion was that none of us had seen a carry, but a couple of plays that were close. Our final analysis was that if we have to think that hard to figure out if it is or isn't a violation, then we stick with not calling it until it calls itself.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I do not see much of a travel. I see a player that is catching the ball with their feet moving. That does not make it a travel IMO. And if you have to look at slow motion replay to determine something, it probably is not as obvious and should not be called.

Peace

I didn't say I needed slow motion to see it. Frankly, it looks clear to me from the camera angle that he catches it with his right foot down, then lefts and replants that right foot. No question it's a travel.

Again, not sure I'd see this on the floor, but that doesn't mean it wasn't a travel. It just means I might have missed it.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

Why am I not surprised someone mentioned a travel.

BTW, I think there was nothing to call on this last play.

Peace

Funny, certain people didn't mention the travels missed in the Georgia high school video, in which all the games were from the state tournament.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Funny, certain people didn't mention the travels missed in the Georgia high school video, in which all the games were from the state tournament.

Which tells me that they somehow think the bigger guys miss these plays on purpose and the self-righteous high school guys are pure to the game and just miss the calls. They will not admit that fact, but it seems true.

Peace