Dunk, then PC Crash - Basket Good?

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Adam

Nah, I didn't realize we were talking about real life frequency. In that case, the entire play is highly unlikely.

What exactly is unlikely? A foul involving a player after the ball is dead (e.g.e dunked the ball)? If so, I don't think it is really that unlikely. A late defender trying to still contest the dunk might not make contact until after the ball is through. It may be close, but due to the way rules are written, we don't really care. The foul is charged and penalized the same until the shooter lands.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

What exactly is unlikely? A foul involving a player after the ball is dead (e.g.e dunked the ball)? If so, I don't think it is really that unlikely. A late defender trying to still contest the dunk might not make contact until after the ball is through. It may be close, but due to the way rules are written, we don't really care. The foul is charged and penalized the same until the shooter lands.

The PC version, regardless of the restricted area.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Adam

The PC version, regardless of the restricted area.

Yeah, probably not likely to have a PC after the ball is through the hoop.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Yeah, probably not likely to have a PC after the ball is through the hoop.

Isn't he still an airborne shooter until he returns to the floor, regardless of where the ball is? What if the defense steps in after shooter jumps, and dunks, and cuts him on the way down. You calling a block or passing?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by OKREF

Isn't he still an airborne shooter until he returns to the floor, regardless of where the ball is? What if the defense steps in after shooter jumps, and dunks, and cuts him on the way down. You calling a block or passing?

I'm looking for an F1.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by OKREF

Isn't he still an airborne shooter until he returns to the floor, regardless of where the ball is? What if the defense steps in after shooter jumps, and dunks, and cuts him on the way down. You calling a block or passing?

Not passing, just saying that the play is probably unlikely. The point was that if there was a defender there early enough to have position for a PC, they're probably going to be going for the block rather than taking a charge after a dunk.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Not passing, just saying that the play is probably unlikely. The point was that if there was a defender there early enough to have position for a PC, they're probably going to be going for the block rather than taking a charge after a dunk.

I see that point.