Louisville @ Notre Dame, Rich's Video Request #2

[APG]

Originally Posted by BLydic

LOL!! There has to be one of these you would call.

In real time? Maybe the second play by 0...probably not. That's the only play in the clip that's worth a question in my opinion. I also wouldn't expect that to be called in a D-I game.

[BLydic]

Originally Posted by APG

In real time? Maybe the second play by 0...probably not. That's the only play in the clip that's worth a question in my opinion. I also wouldn't expect that to be called in a D-I game.

I'll take a maybe

I'm liking what you, Rich, Rut and others are saying, the travel call is the toughest ... hope there's more video throughout the rest of the season to learn from.

[twocentsworth]

ZERO travels in that sequence.....they didn't call any and I wouldn't call any.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by APG

In real time? Maybe the second play by 0...probably not. That's the only play in the clip that's worth a question in my opinion. I also wouldn't expect that to be called in a D-I game.

The 2nd ND player most definitely travelled and it is something that should be called in an NCAA game. It was missed.

[APG]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

The 2nd ND player most definitely travelled and it is something that should be called in an NCAA game. It was missed.

I see that type of play passed on quite often at that level.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by APG

I see that type of play passed on quite often at that level.

Then you need to view some more of John Adams videos b/c he doesn't like these travels being missed.

My crew had a play where a player, who already had a FF1 for an elbow foul, picked up his 5th foul in frustration to missing a lay-up in which there was marginal contact. After our supervisor confirmed our no-call on the missed lay-up his next comment was that the situation would have been avoided if we had called the travel on said player when he made his move to the basket.

So college supervisors are looking if we pick up travels. And so is John Adams. The 2nd ND player very obviously travelled and the fact that is was missed isn't reason to say it's not a call that's made at that level. It just may mean that travelling calls will be a POE again next season.

[APG]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Then you need to view some more of John Adams videos b/c he doesn't like these travels being missed.

My crew had a play where a player, who already had a FF1 for an elbow foul, picked up his 5th foul in frustration to missing a lay-up in which there was marginal contact. After our supervisor confirmed our no-call on the missed lay-up his next comment was that the situation would have been avoided if we had called the travel on said player when he made his move to the basket.

So college supervisors are looking if we pick up travels. And so is John Adams. The 2nd ND player very obviously travelled and the fact that is was missed isn't reason to say it's not a call that's made at that level. It just may means that travelling calls will be a POE again next season.

Well there's a disconnect somewhere...because I'd be more shocked seeing a whistle on this play than not.

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by twocentsworth

ZERO travels in that sequence.....they didn't call any and I wouldn't call any.

You're nuts then.

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

The 2nd ND player most definitely travelled and it is something that should be called in an NCAA game. It was missed.

Exactly.

If #0 for ND isn't going to be called for a travel going across the lane (When his pivot foot is lifted and returns to the floor not once, but twice), we should just delete the traveling violation out of the NCAA rules book. That is about as obviously as it gets. The others I can get with, it might have been ticky-tack to get those, but #0 clearly traveled.

[Texref]

Originally Posted by APG

In real time? Maybe the second play by 0...probably not. That's the only play in the clip that's worth a question in my opinion. I also wouldn't expect that to be called in a D-I game.

Agree completely.