Louisville @ Notre Dame, Rich's Video Request #2

[Rich]

Originally Posted by VaTerp

Watching again #0 does travel when he gets the ball, was distracted by ESP ticker.

No way in real time or even on replay I'm calling that travel on #1 though.

I was referring to 2 travels on 0. I don't know how the flash across the lane can be considered anything other than a travel when that last foot (which has to be the pivot foot) comes back to the floor again.

Nothing on #1.

[VaTerp]

Originally Posted by Rich

I was referring to 2 travels on 0. I don't know how the flash across the lane can be considered anything other than a travel when that last foot (which has to be the pivot foot) comes back to the floor again.

Nothing on #1.

Agreed. 0 travels twice and would think they would have gotten the second one especially.

[BLydic]

Originally Posted by Rich

I was referring to 2 travels on 0.

Two travels on 0? I don't know ... I can see one, but the other would be considered ticky tacky at this level.

[Sharpshooternes]

Originally Posted by BLydic

Two travels on 0? I don't know ... I can see one, but the other would be considered ticky tacky at this level.

I had three although I definately wouldn't hve called the first one by 0,(and you can;t see it very well anyway because of the score on the screen.) Number 1 at the top of the screen does lift his pivot and put it back down.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by BLydic

Two travels on 0? I don't know ... I can see one, but the other would be considered ticky tacky at this level.

I didn't say I'd call the first one -- I wouldn't. I don't go looking for travels that aren't obvious.

But the second one? I think that falls into the obvious category, at least for me it does.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by Rich

I didn't say I'd call the first one -- I wouldn't. I don't go looking for travels that aren't obvious.

But the second one? I think that falls into the obvious category, at least for me it does.

I'm not saying I woul call the first one either, or the one on #1, but the second one by 0 has to be called.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by OKREF

I'm not saying I woul call the first one either, or the one on #1, but the second one by 0 has to be called.

I don't think #1 traveled.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by Rich

I don't think #1 traveled.

Look at it again. Clearly has ball with left foot one the floor, steps with right, picks up left and returns it to floor.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by OKREF

Look at it again.

If you're talking about the toe of #1's pivot foot *maybe* coming off the floor and coming back down, that's not a nit I'd even entertain picking.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by OKREF

Look at it again. Clearly has ball with left foot one the floor, steps with right, picks up left and returns it to floor.

I don't think you can say that, his body is between the camera and the ball and it's not clear when he actually possesses it. I'm with Rich, too small of a nit to try and pick.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by Rich

I didn't say I'd call the first one -- I wouldn't. I don't go looking for travels that aren't obvious.

But the second one? I think that falls into the obvious category, at least for me it does.

Agreed.

It seems that non travel calls which are business as usual in NBA have seeped into the college game and are as about frequent as a three second call. First one I would pass on but two? C'mon.

[jump stop]

Technically Player #0 does travel when he goes across the lane :
He gathered the ball with one foot on floor(left foot) , jumped off of this foot, but did not land simultneously on 2 feet

This play is called a travel only about 1/100 times in a D1 game and rightfully so. Does anyone actually land simultaneously on 2 feet??? Did he gather with one foot on floor or gather with both feet in air (if so he doesn't have to land simultaneously).

I think the bottom line for D1 officials as far as the travel call goes is; if you are not 100% sure don't call it. You will not see a call on the jump stop for not landing simultaneously.

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by jump stop

Technically Player #0 does travel when he goes across the lane :
He gathered the ball with one foot on floor(left foot) , jumped off of this foot, but did not land simultneously on 2 feet

This play is called a travel only about 1/100 times in a D1 game and rightfully so. Does anyone actually land simultaneously on 2 feet??? Did he gather with one foot on floor or gather with both feet in air (if so he doesn't have to land simultaneously).

I think the bottom line for D1 officials as far as the travel call goes is; if you are not 100% sure don't call it. You will not see a call on the jump stop for not landing simultaneously.

Yes, it is a travel. I know our state association has made it very clear. Unless you land simultaneously on a jump stop it is a travel and should be called as such.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by jump stop

Technically Player #0 does travel when he goes across the lane :
He gathered the ball with one foot on floor(left foot) , jumped off of this foot, but did not land simultneously on 2 feet

This play is called a travel only about 1/100 times in a D1 game and rightfully so. Does anyone actually land simultaneously on 2 feet??? Did he gather with one foot on floor or gather with both feet in air (if so he doesn't have to land simultaneously).

I think the bottom line for D1 officials as far as the travel call goes is; if you are not 100% sure don't call it. You will not see a call on the jump stop for not landing simultaneously.

Almost simultaneously is far different from what we see in this video.

[VaTerp]

Originally Posted by jump stop

Technically Player #0 does travel when he goes across the lane :
He gathered the ball with one foot on floor(left foot) , jumped off of this foot, but did not land simultneously on 2 feet

This play is called a travel only about 1/100 times in a D1 game and rightfully so. Does anyone actually land simultaneously on 2 feet??? Did he gather with one foot on floor or gather with both feet in air (if so he doesn't have to land simultaneously).

I think the bottom line for D1 officials as far as the travel call goes is; if you are not 100% sure don't call it. You will not see a call on the jump stop for not landing simultaneously.

I think about 1/100 of this post is NOT BS.

What does both this play have to do with a jump stop?