In the act of shooting?
A1 rebounds the ball and begins the habitual motion to shoot. B1 grabs A1's arm. You have a whistle at this point for a foul. A1 gives up on that attempt then makes a legal step through move to the basket and makes a bank shot.
How do you handle this play? Note: You deem A1 to be in the act of shooting before his arm is grabbed. The step through move was a separate act of shooting. |
I think you can answer your question. The step through isn't continuous motion, it is another move after the whistle. If anything, you can tell A1 to stop on the whistle?
|
It's still a shooting foul if the contact prevents release of the try. I agree with Tom that the second move is an independent try (with a dead ball).
|
It would have to be pretty clear to me that initial try was aborted before I'd wave off the shot and give two free throws.
|
Quote:
I agree that, if in doubt, it was continuous motion. |
Quote:
|
According to the philosophies of many on here as expressed in another recent thread, that would not be a shooting foul at all since he didn't continue to shoot after the foul but made another move prior to actually shooting. :eek:
I don't agree with them, however. :D |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Easy answer to the OP is two shots. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
But no need to hi-jack this thread to an issue that's already been discussed. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:23pm. |