The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Ejected Coach Rules Clarification (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/87881-ejected-coach-rules-clarification.html)

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:05pm

Ejected Coach Rules Clarification
 
Coach is ejected from HS varsity contest and leaves the playing area. Coach also is not allowed to coach the next game. Question is, can he still be at the game? Can he sit on the bleachers, but just not coach? Can he not be in the gym period?

Had never really thought about this part of the penalty. Not seeing anything from the Fed in this regard. Maybe it is handled at the state level?

What brought this up is that a coach was ejected and the 'penalty game' was Senior Night.... :eek:

JRutledge Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:11pm

This is completely a local issue. It will vary based on the state, organization or conference rules involved. No one can answer for every jurisdiction as this is not a playing rules issue.

Peace

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:22pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 821668)
This is completely a local issue. It will vary based on the state, organization or conference rules involved. No one can answer for every jurisdiction as this is not a playing rules issue.

Peace

Fair enough. Then I'd be curious to hear from those that have either been involved in such a situation or know how it has been handled in one's respective jurisdiction.....

JRutledge Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:33pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821671)
Fair enough. Then I'd be curious to hear from those that have either been involved in such a situation or know how it has been handled in one's respective jurisdiction.....

I understand you want answers, but not everyone's rules are same. In my area if you are ejected I believe you cannot be at the game, but that is not something I monitor or know in most cases who was ejected before the my game. It is not something we would enforce as we cannot prevent someone from attending a game. I believe it would be up to those that observed the coach and reported it to the state. And trust me, someone will tell them if they violate this rule.

Peace

Raymond Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821671)
Fair enough. Then I'd be curious to hear from those that have either been involved in such a situation or know how it has been handled in one's respective jurisdiction.....

I don't concern myself with it. If know a coach is suspended due to a previous ejection I just check to make sure he's not on the bench.

But anyway, how would our answers help you? :confused: You should get concrete answers from your officiating association or state governing authority.

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 821679)
I don't concern myself with it. If know a coach is suspended due to a previous ejection I just check to make sure he's not on the bench.

But anyway, how would our answers help you? :confused: You should get concrete answers from your officiating association or state governing authority.

Good grief. I thought this was a forum for basketball related questions...

People ask what games fees are across the country. People ask how different assignors handle certain things. I.E, people are curious on how things are done in different areas. How is this any different?

I'd suggest not posting if you don't have something positive to add. That is, unless you're trying to hit post #5,500 by the end of the month. ;)

tref Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:46pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821684)
Good grief. I thought this was a forum for basketball related questions...

You sir thought wrong! j/k :D

rockchalk jhawk Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:54pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821684)
Good grief. I thought this was a forum for basketball related questions...

People ask what games fees are across the country. People ask how different assignors handle certain things. I.E, people are curious on how things are done in different areas. How is this any different?

I'd say he has a pretty legitimate point. He did say that he wanted to hear how it was handled in YOUR JURISDICTION.

That being said, I don't think you're allowed to be in the gym around these parts, but I've never officially heard that I guess.

bowlingref Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:55pm

If a basketball coach has been ejected and someone has aquestion, I would think that is somewhat basketball related.

rockyroad Wed Feb 08, 2012 02:58pm

It's a valid question...people are just cranky this time of year. Tired from all the games + tax season, you know.

In Washington State, an ejected coach is not allowed to be in the gym at the next game.

Adam Wed Feb 08, 2012 03:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821684)
Good grief. I thought this was a forum for basketball related questions...

People ask what games fees are across the country. People ask how different assignors handle certain things. I.E, people are curious on how things are done in different areas. How is this any different?

I'd suggest not posting if you don't have something positive to add. That is, unless you're trying to hit post #5,500 by the end of the month. ;)

You don't mind if I post to tell you I don't know, do you?

And mbyron, shut up. :D

JRutledge Wed Feb 08, 2012 03:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockchalk jhawk (Post 821692)
I'd say he has a pretty legitimate point. He did say that he wanted to hear how it was handled in YOUR JURISDICTION.

That being said, I don't think you're allowed to be in the gym around these parts, but I've never officially heard that I guess.

It is a legitimate question, but not sure how we are to handle something we do not control. And that is why this question needs to be cognizant of the fact that officials do not take tickets, act as security and tell people who can and cannot come into a facility we do not own.

Peace

mbyron Wed Feb 08, 2012 03:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 821706)
You don't mind if I post to tell you I don't know, do you?

Almost to 19,600.

Raymond Wed Feb 08, 2012 03:51pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821684)
Good grief. I thought this was a forum for basketball related questions...

People ask what games fees are across the country. People ask how different assignors handle certain things. I.E, people are curious on how things are done in different areas. How is this any different?

I'd suggest not posting if you don't have something positive to add. That is, unless you're trying to hit post #5,500 by the end of the month. ;)

You seemed to be asking the question because you have a real-world situation that you are not sure how to handle. So my "something positive to add" portion was "You should get concrete answers from your officiating association or state governing authority."

My answer as to my jurisdiction was "I don't concern myself with it. If know a coach is suspended due to a previous ejection I just check to make sure he's not on the bench."

My own unsolicited input was "But anyway, how would our answers help you?"

My new question is "How have you decided or been told to handle it for the game in question?" assuming you are working the game or in that situation in the future.

Have I met all the elements of a correctable posting error?

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 821712)
You seemed to be asking the question because you have a real-world situation that you are not sure how to handle. So my "something positive to add" portion was "You should get concrete answers from your officiating association or state governing authority."

My answer as to my jurisdiction was "I don't concern myself with it. If know a coach is suspended due to a previous ejection I just check to make sure he's not on the bench."

My own unsolicited input was "But anyway, how would our answers help you?"

My new question is "How have you decided or been told to handle it for the game in question?" assuming you are working the game or in that situation in the future.

Have I met all the elements of a correctable posting error?

There is a real-world situation, but I am neither a state association, an organization, or a conference, so I have nothing to do with it. And I don't recall asking everyone what I should do. Again, just curious as to how it is handled across the country, as I had never really put much thought to it and could think of quite a few scenarios that seemed reasonable.

I'm guessing back on the threads that asked about game fees you probably just posted a breakdown for your area. I doubt you responded by asking, "How would our answers help you?".

Raymond Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:25pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821718)
...
I'm guessing back on the threads that asked about game fees you probably just posted a breakdown for your area. I doubt you responded by asking, "How would our answers help you?".

Apples and oranges. One question is clearly for informational purposes while the other started off as a "clarification" question in relation to a real situation.

I just assume when someone puts forth a real-world basketball question such as this one they are looking for a real-world answer that applies to their situation. :cool:

So, are you saying you are not a basketball official? If you are then how is it handled whereever it is you officiate because you still haven't told us that. If not, then my bad for assuming you were an official.

JRutledge Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:40pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 821724)
Apples and oranges. One question is clearly for informational purposes while the other started off as a "clarification" question in relation to a real situation.

It amazes me the things people get upset about when they ask a question. If you did not want an answer why would you ask in the first place? I guess I will never understand some people here at all.

Peace

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:41pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 821724)
I just assume when someone puts forth a real-world basketball question such as this one they are looking for a real-world answer that applies to their situation. :cool:

So, are you saying you are not a basketball official? If you are then how is it handle whereever it is you officiate. If not, then my bad for assuming you were an official.

Yep, I am looking for real-world answers to how different areas handle this situation. And I got your answer, "I don't concern myself with it." You can determine from the posts to this point which ones I probably deem informative and which ones not so much.

Yep, I am an official. From what I've heard today, the coach was allowed to be a part of the Senior Night ceremony before the game and then left the gym.

JRutledge Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821730)
Yep, I am looking for real-world answers to how different areas handle this situation. And I got your answer, "I don't concern myself with it." You can determine from the posts to this point which ones I probably deem informative and which ones not so much.

Yep, I am an official. From what I've heard today, the coach was allowed to be a part of the Senior Night ceremony before the game and then left the gym.

And if he did, are you going to be the person that makes sure he does not participate? What are you going to do when the administration tells you to go jump off a cliff? You going to throw them out of the gym too?

See, this is why you need to talk to your local people. I would not do a thing and probably would not know this took place. I do not stand out and watch those ceremonies anyway. And if someone came and told me that happen, I would be like, "Oh.....OK."

We only control what goes on between the lines, not who participates in some ceremony that could be in the gym or down the hall. Not my/our concern unless there is a policy in place and even then I do not go looking for trouble.

Peace

Raymond Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:48pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821730)
Yep, I am looking for real-world answers to how different areas handle this situation. And I got your answer, "I don't concern myself with it." You can determine from the posts to this point which ones I probably deem informative and which ones not so much.
...

Yes, but how many were positive as well as informative? And were any helpful and informative, but not positive?

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 04:50pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 821709)
It is a legitimate question, but not sure how we are to handle something we do not control. And that is why this question needs to be cognizant of the fact that officials do not take tickets, act as security and tell people who can and cannot come into a facility we do not own.

Peace

I'd suggest to not make it difficult. You could of said something like, "The IHSA mandates that the coach ________." Or you could have replied, "The conferences in my area say that the coach ___________." Or, if you have no idea, then say "I have no idea."

Either way, I have no idea how ticket taking and crowd security got brought into this...... :D

JRutledge Wed Feb 08, 2012 05:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821733)
I'd suggest to not make it difficult. You could of said something like, "The IHSA mandates that the coach ________." Or you could have replied, "The conferences in my area say that the coach ___________." Or, if you have no idea, then say "I have no idea."

Either way, I have no idea how ticket taking and crowd security got brought into this...... :D

Actually no I should not have said that and it would have been stupid to say that. For one the IHSA does not have policies that we enforce who shows up to a school after an ejection. Not something they ask officials to even report unless you are working a double header and that coach stuck around for the second game. Even then I would not prevent the coach from staying. Also there are no such conference rules either that I have ever been aware of. And since all HS games are under IHSA Jurisdiction, those rules trump all rules from an officiating standpoint.

Also you have not been reading this site very long I see as there are states that ask their officials to do all kinds of things. There is a state that wants the officials to stick around after the game to make sure that sportsmanship is displayed in something like the handshake line. There is no way for anyone here to know what your state wants to do and if I said what my policy was, it may not apply to you at all. Again, your question was not to find out lists of stuff, your question had a real world application and would vary by where you live.

Peace

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 07:06pm

Thanks to Rockchalk and Rocky for actually giving a productive answer to what I thought was a fairly simple question. However, you make want to reconsider said answers as it appears that the question I formulated was futile from inception, thus not warranting a response to begin with.

IUgrad92 Wed Feb 08, 2012 07:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 821731)
And if he did, are you going to be the person that makes sure he does not participate? What are you going to do when the administration tells you to go jump off a cliff? You going to throw them out of the gym too?

See, this is why you need to talk to your local people. I would not do a thing and probably would not know this took place. I do not stand out and watch those ceremonies anyway. And if someone came and told me that happen, I would be like, "Oh.....OK."

We only control what goes on between the lines, not who participates in some ceremony that could be in the gym or down the hall. Not my/our concern unless there is a policy in place and even then I do not go looking for trouble.

Peace

You asked what was done for the local situation. I don't care what was decided, just merely interested as to WHAT would be decided. I'm guessing if it wasn't Senior Night, he wouldn't have been there at all. I'm also guessing that the local assignor told the crew of the decision that was made and to make sure the it was carried out in a reasonable fashion.

I have no clue why some (you) thought I was making the decision for this situation. I've re-read all posts and nowhere did I say "I have to decide what to do." Trust me, if I were, I doubt I'd be coming here for guidance.

Raymond Thu Feb 09, 2012 09:44am

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 821780)
...I'm guessing if it wasn't Senior Night, he wouldn't have been there at all. I'm also guessing that the local assignor told the crew of the decision that was made and to make sure the it was carried out in a reasonable fashion.
...

I have my doubts that the crew would be told to make sure the coach was not in the facility. I don't think we have that authority.

IUgrad92 Thu Feb 09, 2012 11:27am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 821993)
I have my doubts that the crew would be told to make sure the coach was not in the facility. I don't think we have that authority.

Considering it was a home game, I'm sure there were at least a few school personnel that could assist in making happen what needed to happen. It's called using the resources available to you. And I've never had a game where there wasn't gym administration available to get things done for situations, as you say, where we don't have authority. I think that's fairly obvious.

The crew doesn't have to start the game until they're satisfied that things are in order. That's the only authority you need. ;)

Adam Thu Feb 09, 2012 11:35am

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 822041)
Considering it was a home game, I'm sure there were at least a few school personnel that could assist in making happen what needed to happen. It's called using the resources available to you. And I've never had a game where there wasn't gym administration available to get things done for situations, as you say, where we don't have authority. I think that's fairly obvious.

The crew doesn't have to start the game until they're satisfied that things are in order. That's the only authority you need. ;)

I've never heard of officials being told to mess with this. Ever. It's a lot like player eligibility. It's up to the school to comply, and between them and the state if they don't. Similarly, what compliance looks like is beyond my scope.

We enforce ejections and disqualifications, we don't enforce suspensions.

rockyroad Thu Feb 09, 2012 11:43am

IUgrad, I had a game last season where the Head Coach had been ejected and was NOT supposed to be in the gym. Got a call from my assignor on the way to the gym telling us that if the HC was there, don't worry about it, don't try to do anything about it, just call him (the assignor) back after the game and let him know and he would report it to the State.

We have no authority to enforce the State's policy - that's up to the school. We simply report.

SCalScoreKeeper Thu Feb 09, 2012 12:06pm

In my state the coach is disqualified for that contest and suspended for the next.A lot of schools have security in their gym or readily available to enforce an ejection should it become necessary. Attendance at the contest where the coach should be suspended results in automatic forefeiture.Here is California's ejection rule-

1624. COACH EJECTION
Upon ejection, the head or assistant coach shall be disqualified from participating in the remainder of the game and will be ineligible for the team’s next contest. The next contest may not be a forfeited, postponed or canceled game. A second ejection will constitute a two contest suspension and a third ejection will cause suspension for the remainder of the season. A coach who was ejected from the previous contest who, knowingly or unknowingly, participates in or is in attendance at the next contest, will result in the forfeiture of that contest.

QUESTION: What is meant by attendance at a contest?
ANSWER: Attendance is defined as being present at the team bench/area, inside a gymnasium, stadium or playing area. The intent of this rule is that the ejected person is not present at the next contest.
QUESTION: How does the Accountability Rule affect a coach who coaches more than one level of a particular sport?
ANSWER: A coach who has been ejected from a contest may not be in attendance at ANY contest prior to serving his/her mandatory suspension. (i.e.: An ejected JV coach who is also a varsity assistant may NOT be in attendance at any contest until his/her mandatory JV suspension has been completed.)

Raymond Thu Feb 09, 2012 02:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCalScoreKeeper (Post 822056)
In my state the coach is disqualified for that contest and suspended for the next.A lot of schools have security in their gym or readily available to enforce an ejection should it become necessary. Attendance at the contest where the coach should be suspended results in automatic forefeiture.Here is California's ejection rule-

1624. COACH EJECTION
Upon ejection, the head or assistant coach shall be disqualified from participating in the remainder of the game and will be ineligible for the team’s next contest. The next contest may not be a forfeited, postponed or canceled game. A second ejection will constitute a two contest suspension and a third ejection will cause suspension for the remainder of the season. A coach who was ejected from the previous contest who, knowingly or unknowingly, participates in or is in attendance at the next contest, will result in the forfeiture of that contest.

QUESTION: What is meant by attendance at a contest?
ANSWER: Attendance is defined as being present at the team bench/area, inside a gymnasium, stadium or playing area. The intent of this rule is that the ejected person is not present at the next contest.
QUESTION: How does the Accountability Rule affect a coach who coaches more than one level of a particular sport?
ANSWER: A coach who has been ejected from a contest may not be in attendance at ANY contest prior to serving his/her mandatory suspension. (i.e.: An ejected JV coach who is also a varsity assistant may NOT be in attendance at any contest until his/her mandatory JV suspension has been completed.)

Does this also address how it is enforced? Who is responsible for reporting infractions?

Camron Rust Thu Feb 09, 2012 04:30pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by IUgrad92 (Post 822041)
Considering it was a home game, I'm sure there were at least a few school personnel that could assist in making happen what needed to happen. It's called using the resources available to you. And I've never had a game where there wasn't gym administration available to get things done for situations, as you say, where we don't have authority. I think that's fairly obvious.

The crew doesn't have to start the game until they're satisfied that things are in order. That's the only authority you need. ;)

It is not a matter of us having the authority to remove the coach, it is not our place to even say anything about it unless they're doing something in the current game that would get them removed. They're just a spectator (or a coach for which we do not determine eligibility).

If their suspension requires that they be out of the gym, that is an issue for the state/league. If it is reported and confirmed, the state/league will be the one to deal with it. The penalty for not obeying the suspension may be that they forfeit that game (that is what the state has done here when a coach violated his suspension by being in the gym).

RookieDude Thu Feb 09, 2012 06:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 821731)
I do not stand out and watch those ceremonies anyway.

Whoa...how do you guys get out of that?:mad:

Adam Thu Feb 09, 2012 06:18pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RookieDude (Post 822255)
Whoa...how do you guys get out of that?:mad:

Did the two prelim games at senior night Tuesday. Freshman game went OT. JV game went 2 OT. We must have called 120 fouls. Senior night ceremony. Varsity game started more than 90 minutes late.

RookieDude Thu Feb 09, 2012 06:22pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 822256)
Did the two prelim games at senior night Tuesday. Freshman game went OT. JV game went 2 OT. We must have called 120 fouls. Senior night ceremony. Varsity game started more than 90 minutes late.

Wow...90 minutes late!

We were 35 minutes late Tuesday night because of Senior night.

I don't want to sound like it's that big a deal...but, just saying.;)

Raymond Thu Feb 09, 2012 09:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RookieDude (Post 822255)
Whoa...how do you guys get out of that?:mad:

If we know there is a ceremony we ask for the time frames and let game admin know we're going go back to the locker room during the ceremony.

JRutledge Fri Feb 10, 2012 12:01am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RookieDude (Post 822255)
Whoa...how do you guys get out of that?:mad:

Easy, it has nothing to do with us. There was a Senior night tonight and we did not come out until the ceremony was over. No one makes us be there as it is not apart of our job description.

Peace

Adam Fri Feb 10, 2012 02:25am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RookieDude (Post 822260)
Wow...90 minutes late!

We were 35 minutes late Tuesday night because of Senior night.

I don't want to sound like it's that big a deal...but, just saying.;)

Three overtimes will do that when combined with 120 fouls that needed callin.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:52pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1