The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   OT - The Rout is on - 100-2 (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/83510-ot-rout-100-2-a.html)

grunewar Tue Nov 29, 2011 10:22am

OT - The Rout is on - 100-2
 
100-2 middle school hoops blowout may have repercussions - Prep Rally - High SchoolBlog - Yahoo! Sports

We've had this discussion before - GIGDGO.

A basket about every 8 seconds by the starters before they were pulled.

Why schedule these games?

No chance of OT in this one Mark! ;)

fullor30 Tue Nov 29, 2011 11:02am

[QUOTE=grunewar;800561]100-2 middle school hoops blowout may have repercussions - Prep Rally - High SchoolBlog - Yahoo! Sports

We've had this discussion before - GIGDGO.

A basket about every 8 seconds by the starters before they were pulled.

Why schedule these games?

No chance of OT in this one Mark! ;)


Disgusting, starting 5-6 wouldn't see a minute, there is nothing to be learned in a game like this. Minimum 10 passes per possesion, no defense beyond arc.

Please tell me they didn't press.

fullor30 Tue Nov 29, 2011 11:03am

[QUOTE=fullor30;800567]
Quote:

Originally Posted by grunewar (Post 800561)
100-2 middle school hoops blowout may have repercussions - Prep Rally - High SchoolBlog - Yahoo! Sports

We've had this discussion before - GIGDGO.

A basket about every 8 seconds by the starters before they were pulled.

Why schedule these games?

No chance of OT in this one Mark! ;)


Disgusting, starting 5-6 wouldn't see a minute, there is nothing to be learned in a game like this. Minimum 10 passes per possession, no defense beyond arc.

Please tell me they didn't press.


bainsey Tue Nov 29, 2011 11:14am

The thought of cancelling Pike's entire season is ridiculous.

If the coach went gung-ho and played the starters the entire game, and pressed, then I could see criticism. Otherwise, the kids were just playing a game. There's no sense in punishing anyone for that.

Just keep playing.

just another ref Tue Nov 29, 2011 12:32pm

What about the guys on the losing team. Did they run the clock, or make a suggestion to do so?

Rufus Tue Nov 29, 2011 01:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by just another ref (Post 800579)
What about the guys on the losing team. Did they run the clock, or make a suggestion to do so?

That's what I was thinking - do they not have any kind of mercy rule to use? Most HS/sub-varsity do. Maybe they should look into that.

Don't blame the winning coach as it sounds like he did what he could (yanked starters after 2 minutes, no press, told the kids not to play D, etc.). Crazy that they'd have their season cancelled because of this.

bainsey Tue Nov 29, 2011 03:13pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by just another ref (Post 800579)
What about the guys on the losing team. [sic]

What about them? What are you looking to do for them?

Scrapper1 Tue Nov 29, 2011 03:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bainsey (Post 800607)
What about them? What are you looking to do for them?

In the course of play, they could "take the air out" of the ball, and just hold it at midcourt. If the winning coach had instructed his team not to play defense, they could have just let the clock run down for a minute or more on each possession.

Beyond that, the coaches could agree to shorten the length of the quarters to 4 minutes or something like that.

If the winning team really wants to be a good sport, there are legitimate ways to avoid these outcomes.

eyezen Tue Nov 29, 2011 06:16pm

I remember playing in a Freshman game against this one team where we put up like 90+ points. They had maybe 10 or so. They were so pissed that during the 4th quarter they kept inbounding the ball to one of my teammates on purpose who scored like 4 uncontested layups in a row. Of course when we all gravitated toward the basket to get a piece of that action, they thew a long snowbird pass for a bucket. Then our coach almost got into a fight with the other coach in the hallway. Good times.

bainsey Tue Nov 29, 2011 06:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 800608)
In the course of play, they could "take the air out" of the ball, and just hold it at midcourt. If the winning coach had instructed his team not to play defense, they could have just let the clock run down for a minute or more on each possession.

Right, the teams could do that, but I asked what are YOU, the official, looking to do about that? Aside from suggesting shortening the quarters (which I've done once, when it was 52-2 at halftime), I don't see what officials can do about these lopsided games. All you can really do is keep playing, and tell the kids that this happens sometimes, and you have to deal with it accordingly.

Camron Rust Tue Nov 29, 2011 07:18pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by eyezen (Post 800637)
I remember playing in a Freshman game against this one team where we put up like 90+ points. They had maybe 10 or so. They were so pissed that during the 4th quarter they kept inbounding the ball to one of my teammates on purpose who scored like 4 uncontested layups in a row. Of course when we all gravitated toward the basket to get a piece of that action, they thew a long snowbird pass for a bucket. Then our coach almost got into a fight with the other coach in the hallway. Good times.

Up by 90 and pissed that the other team was able to get your team to fall for that play....sounds like your coach was an @$$. He should have smiled and applauded the creativity of those kids.

Camron Rust Tue Nov 29, 2011 07:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bainsey (Post 800641)
Right, the teams could do that, but I asked what are YOU, the official, looking to do about that? Aside from suggesting shortening the quarters (which I've done once, when it was 52-2 at halftime), I don't see what officials can do about these lopsided games. All you can really do is keep playing, and tell the kids that this happens sometimes, and you have to deal with it accordingly.

The only think you can do is hold each team to a standard that matches their abilities.

Contact one way just doesn't have the same effect as the same contact in the other direction. Just like we draw the line at a different point for 6th grade games than we do for varsity games, do it between the two teams. It does't have to be (and probably shouldn't be) dramatic, but you can have an effect.

I've had a game in the past where one small Christian school had a player on the squad who was a special needs kid. They would put him in the game for a couple minutes at a time. The other coach recognized what was happening and was very accepting of our treating them just a bit different by not calling a travel as they shuffled their feet around 25 feet from the basket. They just smiled and nodded as if to say it was OK with him.

This is not all that different when you have even typical youth players who are just at dramatically different stages of development.Some will say that we should call it straight down the middle and make no adjustments. I don't do that. I call the game where I feel it will be most beneficial to both teams.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:09am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1