Mechanics
This pertains to the NCAA mostly but can go with NFHS if possible. Do any of you follow the philosophy of mimicking the illegal contact of the offender?
For example, the defender hit the shooter in the leg, would you signal hit to the leg or just go with the common hit mechanic that is in the rulebook? |
Make The Call ...
Quote:
|
I stick to the mechanics that are required by book. Now, if I have to sell a call I might use a secondary signal, but most times just the ones that are given to us by NCAA and NFHS.
I have seen people used non approved mechanics and it has caused trouble. No reason to draw attention to yourself by using different mechanics. |
Quote:
Now, however, with John Adams in charge, there seems to me to be a shift toward starting to think about possibly talking about someday doing things in a more NBA way. (The RA under the basket, the way officials are evaluated, etc.) So it's possible that the prohibition on "demonstrative" signals may soften soon. But as always, you should check with your assignor(s) to see what he/she wants or expects. |
Anybody Need A Coronary Artery Bypass Graft ???
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
Funny how people are so against The League, but the things they do are eventually picked up at other levels :rolleyes: |
Quote:
Peace |
Non Approved IAABO Signals ...
Here are some non approved signals that we are considering here in IAABO Connecticut:
Change “Delayed Lane Violation” to “Delayed Dead Ball: Withheld Whistle” to allow for delayed free throw violations that do not involve a lane violation, i.e. disconcertion, or three point arc violation. http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5240/...b584dfda_m.jpg Add supplemental “Intentional Foul: Excessive Contact” signal. http://farm7.static.flickr.com/6001/...942a16cb_m.jpg Add “Shooter Has Foot Touching Three Point Line” signal. We already use this signal in Connecticut, but it's not approved by IAABO. http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5274/...b354c999_m.jpg |
Left Up In The Air ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Fouls: Hook/wrap Trip (Same as kicked ball) Knee Excessive Contact (Intentional Foul) Communication: Tipped Directional signal Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Old Signal, New Name ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
The basic hold signal for an off/def hook doesn't exactly tell the tale. Do you all only use the approved forearm hit signal or do you show where the player was hit (elbow hit, arm/shoulder, etc)?? |
It's A Matter Of Semantics ...
Quote:
|
Signal 18 is approved to cover all those situations. It's not necessary to list every single usage in the signal table.
|
Quote:
Ultimately, signals are about communication with everyone in the gym. If the current lot doesn't get the job done effectively, I see no problem in lobbying for a few more. I signaled a tripping foul in a soccer game I did last week (even though such signals are optional in soccer). No way could I do such a thing in basketball, so it felt pretty good (although I'm sure the tripped player might disagree). |
Proof Is In The Pudding ...
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Simple Fix ...
Quote:
I recently served on my local board's training committee, and had a rookie official ask me if it was necessary to give a signal for disconcertion. I pointed him to the IAABO mechanics manual to discover that there was no such signal, by the book, so he should just use the “Delayed Lane Violation” signal, as all of us have been doing for more than twenty-five years. That's when I discovered this odd "error". It should be an easy fix. |
Billy,
With all due respect I have never heard anyone claim this was an issue but you. I do not think it matters what they call it, the signal is obviously used for FT delay situations and all of them that apply. Why you need it spelled out in the chart in detail is really beyond me. Peace |
Right Now, There Is No IAABO Disconcertion Signal ...
Quote:
The lack of a disconcertion signal in the IAABO manual confused a rookie, I noted that "oversight" in the IAABO manual, and it can be easily fixed. My local interpreter will discuss this in a few weeks at the IAABO Fall Seminar. If IAABO International feels the same way as JRutledge does, and doesn't see the need for a change, then my interpreter may bring it up to our state interpreter, who may "approve" it for use in Connecticut, like the “Shooter Has Foot Touching Three Point Line” signal that we already use in Connecticut, even though it's not approved by IAABO. Was the NCAA signal ever labeled, “Delayed Lane Violation”, and then changed, or has it always been labeled, “Delayed Dead Ball: Withheld Whistle”? |
Quote:
Peace |
Good grief.
|
You're A Good Man BktBallRef ...
Quote:
|
I use the approved signals. Signals are a rule, not a mechanic and are therefore legislated by the rule book, not mere suggestions in the manual.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:26am. |