Penalty for Disconcertion . . . by Whom?

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I gave the 'punch' in a camp a few years ago and the observer advised against using it.

I guess this just makes no sense to me. Why would you not give an approved signal that clearly identifies the foul as non-shooting? If the purpose of signals is to communicate, that seems like a pretty good signal to use in that situation.

So let me ask you this: does the assignor tell you not to use the PC signal at the table as well? If not, what do you signal after a crash before the try has been released?